June 23rd, 2024

Fedora has been shipping with a broken screen reader for nine years

Fedora Linux distribution ships with a broken screen reader for nine years, revealing accessibility issues in tech. Debate ensues over responses from Fedora Project and advocate Aral Balkan faces backlash but remains dedicated to accessibility advocacy.

Read original articleLink Icon
Fedora has been shipping with a broken screen reader for nine years

Fedora, a major Linux distribution, has been shipping with a broken screen reader for nine years, highlighting a systemic issue in the tech industry's approach to accessibility. Screen readers are crucial for individuals with disabilities to use computers effectively. While major proprietary operating systems offer functional screen readers, Fedora and other Linux distributions with Wayland default to broken screen readers. The lack of accessibility features in Fedora sparked a debate, with accusations of gaslighting and inadequate responses from the Fedora Project. Aral Balkan, a vocal advocate for accessibility, faced backlash and misinformation, leading to a detailed response addressing personal attacks and misrepresentations. The incident sheds light on the challenges faced by marginalized communities in tech and the importance of prioritizing accessibility in software development. Despite the drama, Balkan remains committed to advocating for accessibility and challenging ableist norms in the industry.

Related

Is 2024 the year of Windows on the Desktop?

Is 2024 the year of Windows on the Desktop?

In 2024, the author reviews Windows 11, highlighting challenges like limited hardware support, lack of installation control, manual driver search, slow updates, and UI lag. They compare favorably to Linux distributions.

Update on GNOME Newton, the Wayland-native accessibility project

Update on GNOME Newton, the Wayland-native accessibility project

The Newton project aims to enhance accessibility on free desktops, focusing on Wayland-protocols, AccessKit, Mutter, Orca, GTK, and libadwaita components. Progress includes running GTK 4 apps in Flatpak sandboxes, with ongoing work to improve Orca functionality on Wayland. Challenges involve optimizing performance and addressing architectural issues for assistive technologies. Future plans may extend support to GNOME Shell UI.

I found an 8 years old bug in Xorg

I found an 8 years old bug in Xorg

An 8-year-old Xorg bug related to epoll misuse was found by a picom developer. The bug caused windows to disappear during server lock, traced to CloseDownClient events. Despite limited impact, the developer seeks alternative window tree updates, emphasizing testing and debugging tools.

Easily upgradeable laptops are making a comeback and I'm here for it

Easily upgradeable laptops are making a comeback and I'm here for it

Easily upgradeable laptops like Lenovo's ThinkPad T14 Gen 5 and T16 Gen 3 models are designed for repairability, receiving a high score from iFixit. This shift aligns with sustainability and right-to-repair trends.

CentOS Linux 7 will reach EOL on Sunday

CentOS Linux 7 will reach EOL on Sunday

CentOS Linux 7 will reach End of Life on June 30, 2024. Users are advised to migrate to Red Hat Enterprise Linux for continued support, with migration tools and consulting services available for a smooth transition.

Link Icon 5 comments
By @amluto - 4 months
Fedora has been shipping with a system that does not have a unified concept of what’s on the screen for years. It’s called GNOME 3. Ever tried to interact with the modal thingy that asks for a WiFi password as though it were a dialog box? It doesn’t work well, because it’s a figment of gnome-shell’s imagination and not actually a dialog box. (Or at least this was the case the last time I tried to figure out what was going on, which was a while ago.) I know very little about how A11y is plumbed under the hood, but I’m not surprised that it struggles with gnome-shell.

I suspect there’s a functioning middle ground between Windows XP-style or X11-style “everything is a window, even security sensitive overlays like the lock screen” and GNOME-style “everything is either a surface with no particular semantics or something produced directly by the shell”.

By @rurban - 4 months
The thing is that they still allowed X11, which has a working screen reader. Just they'll stop shipping X11 with F41, so this time it should really be a blocker. So Aral does have a point. now.
By @LeoPanthera - 4 months
I've vouched this, and am shocked that it was flagged. Since there are no comments, I don't know why it was flagged, but if you're trying to disagree that we live in an ableist culture, flagging this is only proof that you're wrong.
By @phoronixrly - 4 months
Aral still does not miss a chance to look like an a-hole I see. Guess there's no profit for him to fix the screen reader himself, so he's blaming the volunteers.

I've already filtered him from mastodon, sad I can't do this here...

By @pharos92 - 4 months
Aral really comes across as a class-a douche.