July 2nd, 2024

The priest who predicted black holes – in 1783

John Michell, an 18th-century British clergyman, predicted black holes using Newtonian laws, influencing modern understanding despite initial resistance from physicists like Einstein. Michell's innovative ideas shaped cosmic knowledge.

Read original articleLink Icon
The priest who predicted black holes – in 1783

In the 18th century, British clergyman John Michell made groundbreaking predictions about black holes using Newtonian laws, long before Einstein. Michell's work included estimating star density, studying earthquakes, and developing a torsion balance to measure Earth's density. He also hypothesized how gravity could affect light, leading to the concept of black holes. Michell's ideas were ahead of his time, but they were overshadowed until the 20th century when they were rediscovered. Despite Michell's foresight, prominent physicists like Einstein initially resisted the idea of black holes. Michell's dark stars concept, though similar to black holes, did not challenge established beliefs like modern black holes do. Michell's innovative thinking and adherence to Newtonian principles paved the way for understanding these enigmatic cosmic phenomena. His contributions to science, though overlooked in his time, have since been recognized for their significance in shaping our understanding of the universe.

Related

Scientists may have found an answer to the mystery of dark matter

Scientists may have found an answer to the mystery of dark matter

Scientists research dark matter, an invisible substance crucial for understanding the universe. Recent studies propose primordial black holes as a solution, suggesting they could account for dark matter and be detected by gravitational wave detectors.

Primordial Black Holes with QCD Color Charge

Primordial Black Holes with QCD Color Charge

Researchers propose a mechanism for primordial black holes with QCD color charge, potentially part of dark matter. Study by Alonso-Monsalve and Kaiser explores observational implications, shedding light on early Universe understanding.

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Physicists, including Einstein, initially resisted the concept of black holes due to their strangeness and implications of singularities. Despite early skepticism, the existence of black holes has been confirmed, reshaping cosmic understanding.

The surprising behavior of black holes in an expanding universe

The surprising behavior of black holes in an expanding universe

Physicist Nikodem Popławski's study reveals black hole behavior in an expanding universe. Einstein's equations suggest a constant expansion rate at black hole event horizons, challenging previous assumptions and shedding light on the Hubble tension. Popławski's work hints at a link between black holes, wormholes, and dark energy.

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Albert Einstein and peers initially resisted black hole concepts. Despite theoretical roots dating back a century, acceptance came in the 1960s with observational support. Einstein's work laid the foundation, but reluctance persisted due to clashes between evidence and personal beliefs.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @digging - 5 months
> ...there was one person who showed remarkable prescience about black holes...

> According to McCormmach, the existence of invisible stars was a relatively common idea among scientists of the time.

Talk about burying the lede. The life and times of Michell seem irrelevant here, when in fact many were calculating the idea of stars so heavy they would recapture their own light. And they were calculating this based on an incorrect principle of light-as-massive-particles. And these dark stars did not behave at all as black holes do according to modern theories.

So, black holes were not in fact predicted by British clergyman John Michell. This could have been an interesting article if it hadn't tried to force its deceptive headline.

By @IIAOPSW - 5 months
Sure, and the ancient Greeks predicted the heat death of the universe. The premise that all matter has an intrinsic type, and that all types tend to either float or sink relative to the others, and that in the long run all matter will be organized into perfect spheres of homogeneous layers, is totally in line with our modern understanding of entropy.

Every old theory was sort of right if you just ignore all the ways it was wrong and interpret it very liberally.

By @29athrowaway - 5 months
The more mass, the more gravity.

The more gravity, the larger the escape velocity.

But there's a maximum speed in the universe, the speed of light.

If a body has so much mass that the escape velocity is higher than the speed of light, you got a black hole.

By @tocs3 - 5 months
Makes me think of Charles Babage and Ada Lovelace. I do not think either got much recognition until relatively recently.