July 3rd, 2024

Oldest cave art found showing humans and pig

Australian and Indonesian scientists unearthed the world's oldest figurative cave art in Indonesia, dating back 51,200 years. This finding challenges human evolution timelines, emphasizing narrative storytelling's early cultural significance.

Read original articleLink Icon
Oldest cave art found showing humans and pig

Australian and Indonesian scientists have discovered the world's oldest figurative cave art on the Indonesian Island of South Sulawesi. The painting, at least 51,200 years old, depicts a wild pig and three human-like figures, showcasing the capacity for creative thought in early humans. This finding challenges previous notions about the timeline of human evolution and storytelling abilities. The discovery suggests that narrative storytelling was a crucial aspect of early human culture in Indonesia. The art represents an evolution in human thought processes, leading to the emergence of art and science. The dating method used for this discovery may lead to re-dating of other cave art sites worldwide, potentially pushing back the origins of representational art further. This finding reinforces the idea that representational art likely originated in Africa before spreading to other regions. The discovery sheds new light on the role of storytelling in the history of art and human evolution.

Related

Structures discovered in the Pacific could change our understanding of Earth

Structures discovered in the Pacific could change our understanding of Earth

Researchers found unique structures in the Pacific Ocean challenging traditional beliefs about Earth's early history. Rock formations in South Africa and New Zealand suggest ancient seismic activities shaped the planet, potentially influencing the emergence of life.

Does a cave beneath Pembroke Castle hold key to fate of early Britons?

Does a cave beneath Pembroke Castle hold key to fate of early Britons?

A cave beneath Pembroke Castle in Wales, Wogan Cavern, unveils prehistoric treasures like ancient bones and tools. Scientists aim to understand Neanderthals' presence and Homo sapiens' settlement in Britain. Excavation promises valuable insights.

The Oldest Known Burial Site in the World Wasn't Created by Our Species

The Oldest Known Burial Site in the World Wasn't Created by Our Species

Paleontologists in South Africa unearthed the oldest burial site globally, revealing Homo naledi remains. Dating back to 200,000 BCE, this challenges human evolution beliefs, suggesting early complex behaviors and symbolic practices.

Was the Dingo Born to Be Wild?

Was the Dingo Born to Be Wild?

Researchers propose that dingoes in Australia were kept as pets by First Australians, supported by burial evidence dating back 800-2,000 years. Dingoes were interred with humans, indicating a close relationship. They aided in hunting and guarded campsites, impacting Aboriginal society. Dingoes were seen as spiritually significant but lacked dog-like loyalty. Studies at Curracurrang showed signs of human care in elderly dingoes. Genetic links to New Guinea singing dogs raise questions about their origin, sparking debates on their lineage as descendants of dogs or wolves.

Aboriginal ritual passed down over 12,000 years, cave find shows

Aboriginal ritual passed down over 12,000 years, cave find shows

Researchers unearthed a 12,000-year-old Aboriginal healing ritual in Australia's Cloggs Cave. The discovery showcases the enduring power of oral traditions in passing down ancient practices, emphasizing the importance of Indigenous cultural heritage.

Link Icon 18 comments
By @dash2 - 5 months
"The discovery pushes back the time that modern humans first showed the capacity for creative thought."

Hmm. The very simplest model you could have of this would be the German Tank Problem [1]. If discoveries of X (e.g. art, hunting tools, whatever) are made at random, i.e. evidence of X is not more likely to be destroyed as time passes, then you are sampling times from a distribution with a maximum of the first invention of X, and the best estimator for this is (m-1)(k-1)/(k-2) where m is the oldest discovery and k is the number of discoveries.

In particular, a new record for oldest art will almost always push your estimate up (as long as k is large so (k-1)/(k-2) is about 1). But you should also be taking into account all the discoveries of art which aren't records. This matters especially when k is not yet big. This page only lists 30-40 pieces of paleolithic art [2].

A better model would take into account that older stuff is less likely to be discovered because e.g. rocks erode. I wonder if anyone has done this.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_tank_problem [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Stone_Age_art

By @riazrizvi - 5 months
> it would show humans at the time had the capacity for abstract thinking

This was 50,000 years ago, they were Homo Sapiens, we are 200,000 years old. We can see abstract thinking through the advancement of our early tools and through linguistic studies that trace lineage of abstract language patterns to points in time using archeological knowledge of migration periods. So this confirms it further I guess.

By @lkrubner - 5 months
The distance between the known examples of early art also further pushes back the date when humans became capable of art. Unless you believe that people from Indonesia painted this art 51,000 years ago and then migrated to Europe, and thus brought art to Europe via migration, then instead you would have to believe that the artists who eventually arose in Europe and Indonesia had a common ancestor who was capable of art. If we have art in Indonesia at 51,000 years ago, and art in Europe about 35,000 years ago, and if the last common ancestor of those 2 populations lived 100,000 years ago (hypothetically) then you'd have to believe that humans have been capable of this kind of art for at least 100,000 years.
By @smokel - 5 months
There appears to be some more information here, also on the dating method used (which apparently is laser ablation U-series analysis):

https://news.griffith.edu.au/2024/07/04/cave-painting-in-ind...

I'm not entirely convinced about the human-like figures, though. Does anyone have more background knowledge on how one can jump to that conclusion?

Edit: found the publication in Nature. The picture circulating in the media is a tracing of the actual painting, which is nearly impossible to see on the actual rock. Enjoy! https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07541-7

By @nuz - 5 months
Almost rorschach painting levels of ambiguity in that thing
By @mharig - 5 months
"Something seems to have happened around 50,000 years ago, shortly after which all other species of human such as Neanderthals and the so-called Hobbit died out."

Isn't the current estimate, that Neanderhals and Danisovans died out around 45000 years ago? Or does he refer only to the region of the cave? And the Homo floresiensis died out 10000 years ago (or 100 years ago, or he still exists, if some Anthropologists are right).

And what I do not understand about the cave archeology: nobody who lives as a nomadic hunter & gatherer lives in a cave. The climate inside is near unbearable if you are accustomed to free air. Maybe one can stay a little time in the mouth of a cave. When the weather conditions outside are as ugly as they can get. Or if the population density got so bad, that an easy to defend place is necessary. The findings IMO are more probable a result of population dynamics than brain development.

By @swayvil - 5 months
I heard that pigs, pre-selective-breeding, were pretty cute

https://www.leidenmedievalistsblog.nl/images/uploads/_fullla...

By @pyinstallwoes - 5 months
"These hand paintings in Sumpang Bita cave in South Sulawesi were once thought to be among the oldest paintings in the world at 39,000 years"

Why are these cave paintings with hands all over the world? It is kind of ominous to think of the reasons and conditions why they are found everywhere.

By @InDubioProRubio - 5 months
If you want to be immortal as an artist, paint your works on cave walls, for that deep time gallery.

It would be cool to have a history painting, of all that happened on earth as we know it today. Similar to the empires history painted in the foundation in a cave. All those discoveries, all those triumphs and failures. One huge picture.

It would also make sense to search for similar painted caves near caves where such paintings are discovered, expecting filled up cave entrances and collapsed entrances (erosion, ocean, etc.) . Goto outdo the Johnosons next door. Even back then.

By @malkosta - 5 months
Curiosity: in Brazil, Serra da Capivara National Park, there are painting form 30000 years ago and artifacts from 50000 years ago...which challenges the theory that man came to america 12000 years ago via bering strait.

Source: https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parque_nacional_de_la_Sierra_d...

By @ojo-rojo - 5 months
How did humans cross these oceans and seas 50 thousand years ago? To land on the Indonesian islands, South Pacific islands, Australia, New Zealand... Did they have massive ships that we'll never know about? Did they learn how to sail? Was it just small rafts and canoes?

Oh, the sea-faring stories these people must have told.

By @aprilthird2021 - 5 months
The way they keep pushing things back such neat round numbers makes it feel like when tech evangelists say "Oh yeah we'll have everyone in self driving cars / BTC at $1M / safe AGI in 5 years / 10 years / 20 years / etc."

I know there's science behind the dating of these artifacts, but it just feels that way to me.

By @einpoklum - 5 months
Forget the cave art, that place is just gorgeous!

Sulawesi: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Sulawesi&iax=images&ia=images

By @odyssey7 - 5 months
The human body and the human mind are perfectly fitted to one another. They co-evolved.

Any fundamental change in the human brain would imply a fundamental change in the human form, to enable acting on the enhanced understanding. Otherwise, the enhanced understanding would be useless for survival.

The contrapositive would mean that for as long as the human form has been about the same, human ingenuity and creativity have also remained about the same.

If you want to locate when human creativity and ingenuity began, it will have been at or before the basic structure of the hands, larynx, feet, eyes, etc. came to be.

By @permo-w - 5 months
I'd like to see generative AI try to reconstruct the full image