July 19th, 2024

Instrumenting Python GIL with eBPF

The Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) in Python simplifies memory management but hinders performance in multi-threaded, CPU-bound programs. Coroot explains GIL's impact on Python apps, measuring it with eBPF for insights and monitoring efficiency.

Read original articleLink Icon
Instrumenting Python GIL with eBPF

Python's Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) simplifies memory management but limits performance in multi-threaded, CPU-bound programs. Coroot explains the impact of the GIL on Python applications and how to measure it using eBPF. By instrumenting the take_gil function, they track lock acquisition time, even in stripped Python interpreters. Using eBPF uprobes and uretprobes, they record start times and calculate lock acquisition durations. The process involves finding symbols in binaries like libpython or interpreter files. By delving into CPython's implementation of the GIL, they uncover the mechanisms behind acquiring the lock using POSIX threads. Through eBPF programs, they monitor pthread_cond_timedwait calls to measure GIL latency, providing insights into Python application performance. Coroot's agent automates this monitoring without code changes, offering visibility into GIL impact. This approach allows engineers to assess the GIL's effects before considering language changes, emphasizing the importance of measurement in decision-making. Coroot's Python GIL monitoring is available in version 1.3.1, enabling users to understand system behavior effectively.

Related

Coverage at a Crossroads

Coverage at a Crossroads

Coverage.py is evolving to reduce execution-time overhead by adopting SlipCover's low-overhead approach for code coverage. Python 3.12's sys.monitoring improves line coverage, but challenges remain for branch coverage. SlipCover's method shows promise, requiring adjustments for optimal results.

What's up Python? Django get background tasks, a new REPL, bye bye gunicorn

What's up Python? Django get background tasks, a new REPL, bye bye gunicorn

Several Python updates include Django's background task integration, a new lightweight Python REPL, Uvicorn's multiprocessing support, and PyPI blocking outlook.com emails to combat bot registrations, enhancing Python development and security.

How eBPF is shaping the future of Linux and platform engineering

How eBPF is shaping the future of Linux and platform engineering

eBPF, developed by Daniel Borkmann, revolutionizes Linux by enabling custom programs in the kernel. It enhances networking, security, and observability, bridging monolithic and microkernel architectures for improved performance and flexibility.

Instrumenting Python GIL with eBPF

Instrumenting Python GIL with eBPF

Python's Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) simplifies memory management but limits performance in multi-threaded, CPU-bound programs. Coroot explains GIL impact and measurement using eBPF, offering insights and automation in version 1.3.1 for Python users.

Free-threaded CPython is ready to experiment with

Free-threaded CPython is ready to experiment with

CPython 3.13 introduces free-threading to enhance performance by allowing parallel threads without the GIL. Challenges like thread-safety and ABI compatibility are being addressed for future adoption as the default build.

Link Icon 6 comments
By @polotics - 10 months
Wow, 36ms per second is only 3.6% of the time. Python waiting on the GIL is then a pretty overblown problem, as this is not very significant. I wonder if this measure could be run on apps built with various frameworks. I expect that with uvloop and all, the percentage would be even less.
By @ablekh - 10 months
Here is another post describing an alternative approach to instrumenting Python GIL: https://www.maartenbreddels.com/perf/jupyter/python/tracing/....
By @noident - 10 months
>Every Python developer has heard about the GIL

Sadly, that is not the world we live in.

I've cleaned up dozens of applications written by people with flawed understandings of threads, multiprocessing, and asyncio. I don't even blame the developers for this; it's a glaring language design problem.

If you need parallelism, Python is not the language you should reach for. Nobody ever takes my word for it until it's release day and the product is a broken pile of spaghetti code.