Implementing and Improving Skiplists
Matt Hall analyzes skiplists, a data structure enhancing binary trees' efficiency. He discusses implementation in Zig, performance issues, and suggests using dynamic arrays for pointers, though initial tests show increased resource usage.
Read original articleMatt Hall discusses the implementation and performance of skiplists, a data structure that simplifies the complexities of balanced binary trees. Skiplists consist of multiple levels of linked lists, where each level contains a subset of the data from the level below, allowing for efficient searching similar to binary search trees. The author explains the process of inserting and retrieving values in a skiplist, emphasizing the use of a random number generator to determine the levels at which a new value should be inserted.
The implementation is demonstrated using Zig programming language, detailing the structure of nodes and the algorithms for descending to find insertion points and ascending to insert new values. Performance benchmarks indicate that the majority of time is spent in the descent operation, raising concerns about cache efficiency due to pointer chasing.
To improve performance, Hall suggests modifying the node structure to use a dynamic array of pointers instead of individual pointers for downward links. However, initial tests show that this change results in a 20% increase in wall time and memory usage, indicating that while the new structure may be more cache-friendly, it does not yield the expected performance benefits. The article concludes with a reflection on the challenges of optimizing data structures and the importance of careful benchmarking to assess performance improvements accurately.
Related
Binary Search Tree with SIMD
Clément Jean presents a cache-friendly algorithm for binary search trees in Go, optimizing memory access with SIMD operations. The approach enhances search efficiency, demonstrated through benchmark tests, and suggests broader applications in data structures.
Ask HN: Fast data structures for disjoint intervals?
The author seeks recommendations for innovative data structures to improve read speeds for managing disjoint time intervals, noting that existing solutions often do not outperform simple ordered maps.
Implementing and Improving Skiplists
Matt Hall discusses skiplists as an alternative to balanced binary trees, focusing on implementation and improvement. Skiplists offer efficiency in data insertion and retrieval but face challenges in optimizing cache utilization with proposed solutions showing mixed performance results.
Yeah, because they give you pretty darn strong deterministic guarantees.
> Luckily the world of computer science has a data structure that is far easier to implement and has similar properties: the skiplist.
It's far easier to implement... and it doesn't provide the same guarantees.
Is it winter yet?
Related
Binary Search Tree with SIMD
Clément Jean presents a cache-friendly algorithm for binary search trees in Go, optimizing memory access with SIMD operations. The approach enhances search efficiency, demonstrated through benchmark tests, and suggests broader applications in data structures.
Ask HN: Fast data structures for disjoint intervals?
The author seeks recommendations for innovative data structures to improve read speeds for managing disjoint time intervals, noting that existing solutions often do not outperform simple ordered maps.
Implementing and Improving Skiplists
Matt Hall discusses skiplists as an alternative to balanced binary trees, focusing on implementation and improvement. Skiplists offer efficiency in data insertion and retrieval but face challenges in optimizing cache utilization with proposed solutions showing mixed performance results.