July 27th, 2024

Hosting the Olympics has become financially untenable, economists say

Hosting the Olympics is becoming financially unfeasible due to rising costs and negative impacts. The IOC aims for a sustainable approach in Paris, reducing expenses and addressing long-term financial burdens.

Read original articleLink Icon
Hosting the Olympics has become financially untenable, economists say

Hosting the Olympics has increasingly become financially unfeasible, according to economists. The costs associated with the Games have ballooned in recent decades, leading to budget overruns, long-term debts, and negative social and environmental impacts. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) aims to address these issues with the upcoming Paris Games, which are projected to cost under $10 billion, a significant reduction compared to previous events. This shift is partly due to a dwindling number of cities willing to host the Games, as past experiences have shown them to be financially disastrous.

Historically, cities have faced cost overruns exceeding 100% for recent Olympics, with extravagant spending on infrastructure and facilities. For instance, the 2008 Beijing Games cost over $40 billion, while the 2014 Sochi Games exceeded $50 billion. Despite claims of economic benefits, many cities experience long-term financial burdens, including maintenance costs for underused facilities and displacement of lower-income residents.

The IOC's Agenda 2020 aims to make future Games more sustainable, with Paris focusing on minimal permanent infrastructure and environmental initiatives. However, experts caution that the economic impact of hosting the Olympics is often overstated, with many potential visitors deterred by the event. The long-term viability of the Olympics may depend on a fundamental rethinking of how these events are organized and financed to ensure they do not become a financial burden for host cities.

Link Icon 14 comments
By @Aeolun - 3 months
> “All Games, without exception, have cost overrun,” researchers wrote. “For no other type of megaproject is this the case, not even the construction of nuclear power plants or the storage of nuclear waste.”

Have these people been living under a rock? Literally ever megaproject—even much smaller ones—I’ve heard of in the past 10 years has had overruns much higher than 100%

By @SoftTalker - 3 months
Stop trying to outdo the last host's opening ceremony. That boat procession in the rain was a disaster, and whatever they were trying to do with the masked man carrying the torch was absurd. Just have each county's athletes march around the stadium like they used to.

Focus on having good venues for the competition (that doesn't necessarily mean you have to build new ones) that's what it's about.

By @poidos - 3 months
I've always thought the summer games should be in Greece each time, with a different co-host country to set the theme etc. Much less waste (you're using the same stadiums and grounds etc), consistent viewing times, and scheduling. Not sure where the winter games could be but I think the same for that too.
By @AlbertCory - 3 months
Bent Flyvbjerg has made a career of analyzing very large projects and why they turn out so badly. Lest we get smug in this techie corner of the world, he found that large ERP projects are terrible even in the context of large projects. Anyhow:

This headline made me think, "So you're just now discovering this?" Montreal was a disaster; LA 1984 ran a surplus. Cities that already have the sports venues can do all right; other cities have learned by now that building a whole bunch of new stuff is foolhardy.

> To ensure true long-term viability of the Olympics, Matheson, Zimbalist and Phalin said it may come down to designating a single city or rotating through a couple of cities to serve as permanent hosts for the games.

Right: LA, London / Paris, Sydney. All of these could farm out some events to other places, like surfing in French Polynesia. Done.

By @orwin - 3 months
It seems misomusie is much, much more prevalent than I thought. I know Rap enjoyers who listened to Gojira, Lennon and Piaf for the first their life and who were boulversed (I've seen people cry), and a few metal/classical music enjoyers who enjoyed the rap parts. 'Les machines de l' île' once again showed to me they were the greatest mechanical artists (sorry for Korean people: I've seen some of your art in Venise permanent exposition, it's really good, exceptionally good even, but live art will always surpass museum art in my mind). Also: people will now remember Parkour is a French sport, and video-games are now officially a legitimate art I think (I never played assassin's creed, but everybody recognized it, right?). One thing that I didn't like: the Algerian delegation shouldn't have had to bring their own flowers, it should have been an happening organized by Jolly. Still a beautiful, artful moment.

And the costs are 5 billion less than the Tokyo Olympics, so I guess it'll be OK.

By @massysett - 3 months
The linked news article doesn’t describe how it arrived at its cost figures. Suppose a city widens a freeway before hosting the Games. The widened freeway is used afterward. Is this a “cost”? Does it make sense to count it as one?

Maybe the underlying paper discusses this. Hopefully it does as it’s an important question.

By @0cf8612b2e1e - 3 months
Great, do publicly funded sports stadiums next.
By @Nasrudith - 3 months
I cynically thought that the massive overspending was the reason it exists at this point, hosting the Olympics being one big money laundering operation to give an excuse to take out loans and pay the connected without even having to fit your graft into a normal budget. That so many kleptocrats want to host is a further strong hint. Which cynically might be the real reason behind the push for reduced building, it becoming an embarrassment like FIFA's corruption scandals from nearly a decade ago.
By @xenospn - 3 months
Arts and culture have never been financially beneficial. Neither are universal healthcare and making cities accessible. Sometimes the benefit is beyond finances.
By @sys_64738 - 3 months
By @mensetmanusman - 3 months
The world should fund the creation of a new island.
By @klipklop - 3 months
The bread and circus scam has always existed to grift tax money. It’s all one big money grab that people for some reason watch and get emotionally invested in.
By @paulcole - 3 months
So? The Olympics are really cool. And there’s always more money. Does anybody think the Olympics are what’s going to be the end of Los Angeles in 2028?