Oshit: Seven Deadly Sins of Bad Open Source Research
Open source research has gained popularity but faces issues like misuse and poor practices. Bellingcat outlines seven mistakes that undermine integrity, emphasizing accuracy and transparency over speed in sensitive situations.
Read original articleOpen source research has gained credibility and popularity, especially during crises like the war in Gaza, but this rise has also led to misuse and poor practices among researchers. Bellingcat identifies seven common mistakes in open source research that can undermine its integrity. First, failing to provide original sources makes verification difficult, as many social media accounts repost content without proper attribution. Second, researchers must avoid letting personal biases influence their work, acknowledging uncertainties in their findings. Third, archiving material is crucial, as online content can disappear, complicating future investigations. Fourth, lacking context can lead to misinterpretations of events, particularly in conflict monitoring. Fifth, incorrect use of tools and data interpretation can result in false conclusions, highlighting the need for proper training. Sixth, editing footage can obscure vital information, making it harder to analyze content accurately. Lastly, the rush to be first in reporting can lead to significant errors, such as misidentifying individuals involved in incidents. Bellingcat emphasizes that open source research should prioritize accuracy and transparency over speed, as mistakes can have serious consequences, especially in sensitive situations. By recognizing these pitfalls, both researchers and consumers of open source information can improve the quality and reliability of their work.
Related
Nobody knows what's going on
Misinformation's impact on beliefs, reliance on unreliable sources, and human tendency to trust comforting information are discussed. Difficulty in discerning truth and consequences of widespread misinformation are highlighted.
Not all 'open source' AI models are open: here's a ranking
Researchers found large language models claiming to be open source restrict access. Debate on AI model openness continues, with concerns over "open-washing" by tech giants. EU's AI Act may exempt open source models. Transparency and reproducibility are crucial for AI innovation.
So you want to compete with or replace open source
The article delves into open source software's evolution, business challenges, and emerging movements like "post-open" and "Fair Source." It questions their ability to balance commercial interests with open source collaboration.
Linus Torvalds: XZ Utils Breach Raises Questions About Trust in Open Source [video]
The video discusses trust in open source development, highlighting security challenges, breaches, and ethical implications. It emphasizes the Linux kernel's trust network through in-person verification to prevent attacks effectively.
A Brief Note on the CrowdStrike Outage and "Tech Influencer" YouTube
The article critiques low-level tech influencer videos on YouTube, highlighting inaccuracies about Windows systems and the CrowdStrike outage. It calls for responsible content creation prioritizing accurate, well-researched information over misinformation.
Related
Nobody knows what's going on
Misinformation's impact on beliefs, reliance on unreliable sources, and human tendency to trust comforting information are discussed. Difficulty in discerning truth and consequences of widespread misinformation are highlighted.
Not all 'open source' AI models are open: here's a ranking
Researchers found large language models claiming to be open source restrict access. Debate on AI model openness continues, with concerns over "open-washing" by tech giants. EU's AI Act may exempt open source models. Transparency and reproducibility are crucial for AI innovation.
So you want to compete with or replace open source
The article delves into open source software's evolution, business challenges, and emerging movements like "post-open" and "Fair Source." It questions their ability to balance commercial interests with open source collaboration.
Linus Torvalds: XZ Utils Breach Raises Questions About Trust in Open Source [video]
The video discusses trust in open source development, highlighting security challenges, breaches, and ethical implications. It emphasizes the Linux kernel's trust network through in-person verification to prevent attacks effectively.
A Brief Note on the CrowdStrike Outage and "Tech Influencer" YouTube
The article critiques low-level tech influencer videos on YouTube, highlighting inaccuracies about Windows systems and the CrowdStrike outage. It calls for responsible content creation prioritizing accurate, well-researched information over misinformation.