Rand Paul: KOSA is not the solution for protecting children from social media
Rand Paul criticizes the Kids Online Safety Act, arguing it could lead to censorship and restrict free speech by imposing vague duties on platforms, potentially stifling important discussions and content regulation.
Read original articleRand Paul argues that the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) is not an effective solution for protecting children from the dangers of social media. He expresses concern that KOSA would impose a significant duty of care on internet platforms, requiring them to design their sites to mitigate mental health issues like anxiety and depression. Paul believes this could lead to censorship and restrict free speech, as platforms may avoid hosting content that could be deemed harmful to avoid liability. He points out that the bill lacks clear definitions for terms like "mental health disorder," which could lead to arbitrary enforcement and content regulation. Paul questions whether platforms would need to censor discussions on sensitive topics, such as war or pro-life messages, due to potential mental health impacts. He emphasizes that KOSA could result in excessive content regulation, stifling important discussions necessary for a healthy society. Paul argues that government mandates and censorship are not the answer to online safety concerns, advocating instead for parental guidance and the preservation of free expression as the best means to protect children online. He notes that various advocacy groups across the political spectrum oppose KOSA, highlighting a shared concern about its implications for free speech and content regulation.
Related
Senate to Vote on Web Censorship Bill Disguised as Kids Safety
The Senate will vote on the Kids Online Safety Act, which aims to protect minors online but faces criticism for potential free speech restrictions and inadequate support for mental health resources.
The Kids Online Safety Act and the Tyranny of Laziness
The Kids Online Safety Act aims to regulate content recommendation systems but raises concerns about censorship, free speech, and potential overreach in defining "harmful" content, complicating compliance for tech companies.
The KOSA Internet Censorship Bill Just Passed the Senate
The Senate passed the KOSA Internet Censorship Bill, allowing government lawsuits against websites for causing minors' mental distress, raising concerns about censorship and free speech, especially regarding sensitive topics.
Kids Online Safety Act passes Senate despite concerns it will harm kids
The Kids Online Safety Act passed the Senate with a 91-3 vote, aiming to regulate data collection from minors and address harmful platform features, but faces skepticism in the House.
Teens Lobbying Against the Kids Online Safety Act
Over 300 high school students lobbied against the Kids Online Safety Act, fearing it could limit access to vital information online while emphasizing the need for youth voices in legislative discussions.
Well intended law that will increase the surface area for abuse over small business owners, while the big boys simply go about their business
ADA shakedowns are well documented. I remember this prominent example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22231344
There were other examples targeting doctors but thats the one I vividly recall
Related
Senate to Vote on Web Censorship Bill Disguised as Kids Safety
The Senate will vote on the Kids Online Safety Act, which aims to protect minors online but faces criticism for potential free speech restrictions and inadequate support for mental health resources.
The Kids Online Safety Act and the Tyranny of Laziness
The Kids Online Safety Act aims to regulate content recommendation systems but raises concerns about censorship, free speech, and potential overreach in defining "harmful" content, complicating compliance for tech companies.
The KOSA Internet Censorship Bill Just Passed the Senate
The Senate passed the KOSA Internet Censorship Bill, allowing government lawsuits against websites for causing minors' mental distress, raising concerns about censorship and free speech, especially regarding sensitive topics.
Kids Online Safety Act passes Senate despite concerns it will harm kids
The Kids Online Safety Act passed the Senate with a 91-3 vote, aiming to regulate data collection from minors and address harmful platform features, but faces skepticism in the House.
Teens Lobbying Against the Kids Online Safety Act
Over 300 high school students lobbied against the Kids Online Safety Act, fearing it could limit access to vital information online while emphasizing the need for youth voices in legislative discussions.