August 3rd, 2024

San Francisco Takes Harder Line Against Homeless Camps, Defying Its Reputation

San Francisco Mayor London Breed has adopted a stricter approach to homeless encampments, allowing citations and offering bus tickets to encourage relocation, amid voter frustration over persistent encampments and drug use.

Read original articleLink Icon
San Francisco Takes Harder Line Against Homeless Camps, Defying Its Reputation

San Francisco Mayor London Breed has adopted a tougher stance on homeless encampments, directing city officials to issue citations and offer free bus tickets to encourage homeless individuals to leave the area. This decision comes amid growing frustration from voters over persistent encampments and open drug use in the city. Despite previous attempts to clear sidewalks near the Department of Motor Vehicles, homeless individuals have repeatedly returned, often rejecting offers of shelter. Mayor Breed emphasized the need for "tough love" and announced that police could now cite homeless campers for illegal lodging if they refuse shelter, with potential jail time as a consequence.

The mayor's approach marks a shift from San Francisco's historically compassionate policies towards homelessness, influenced by a recent Supreme Court ruling that grants cities greater authority to enforce anti-camping laws. Governor Gavin Newsom has also encouraged local leaders to dismantle encampments. Critics argue that this strategy is cruel and fails to address the root causes of homelessness, while some mayoral challengers propose alternative solutions, such as increasing shelter beds and rent-controlled apartments.

In the initial days of the new enforcement, city workers engaged with homeless individuals, resulting in the removal of tents and a small number accepting shelter. However, many declined assistance, and some returned to set up new encampments shortly after being cleared. The ongoing situation highlights the complexities of addressing homelessness in San Francisco amidst political pressures and community concerns.

Link Icon 11 comments
By @themanmaran - 9 months
I'd love to see some real action here, but it seems more like general pre-election optics than anything. The sidewalk situation in SF is absurd. At least in Mission every few blocks I need to step out in the street to walk around camps.

The bus policy has been going on for a while, just declined during covid. It always comes under scrutiny, but the actual offer is to reconnect homeless people with family and cover bus/train costs to fulfill that. Not always as heartless as the critics make it out to be.

By @andirk - 9 months
My unpopular opinion: If someone continuously refuses services that offer a _life of decency_ (private room/bath, food, etc, not just a shelter but of comfort), then they become a ward of the state and given the rights and amenities of a child, because, regardless of their age, they simply cannot take care of themself. We have many laws and protections for minors for this exact reason.

I don't care how much it costs. Our current strategy costs a lot and solves nothing.

By @AlbertCory - 9 months
By @maerF0x0 - 9 months
> “What is happening now is a quick and performative election-year gimmick,” he said.

This is exactly what I was thinking. This article[1] seems to suggest is started around Oct 2023 though.

[1]: https://www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/london-breeds-...

By @Gimpei - 9 months
This is a direct and predictable consequence of anti housing policies. Decry it all you like, but unless you actually vote out the left-NIMBY supervisors who have a majority on the board, you are part of the problem.
By @brigadier132 - 9 months
I'm hopeful for San Francisco, hopefully it lasts past the election
By @xenospn - 9 months
“Encourage”. Right.
By @UIUC_06 - 9 months
> he found shelters too stressful

> The threat of jail won’t convince him to stay in a shelter, which already feels like jail

So there you have it. Giving them a free bed won't do it. I have a feeling that even giving them a room at the Fairmont wouldn't do it.