In Japanese You Need a Dictionary to Count Things
Japanese counting uses specific counter words called josuushi for different nouns, with around 500 types. This complex system can confuse even native speakers, despite simplifications that may cause ambiguity.
Read original articleJapanese counting involves a complex system that requires the use of specific counter words, known as josuushi, to quantify nouns. While basic counting from one to ten appears straightforward, the intricacies arise when attempting to count objects. Each type of noun necessitates a different counter; for instance, "two books" is expressed as "ni-satsu," while "two carrots" becomes "ni-hon." There are approximately 500 different josuushi in the Japanese language, each tailored to specific categories of items, such as 人 (nin) for people and 枚 (mai) for flat objects. This system can be confusing, even for native speakers, as many struggle to remember the correct counters. Simplifications exist, such as using the generic counter つ (tsu) for inanimate objects, but these shortcuts can lead to ambiguity. The necessity of counters in Japanese contrasts with languages like English, where counting is often more direct. The evolution of this counting system may stem from historical linguistic developments and social dynamics, making it a unique feature of the language. Despite its complexity, the system serves its purpose, allowing over a billion speakers to communicate effectively.
- Japanese counting requires specific counter words for different nouns.
- There are around 500 josuushi, each designated for particular categories.
- Native speakers often struggle to remember the correct counters.
- Simplified counting methods exist but can lead to ambiguity.
- The evolution of this system reflects historical and social linguistic dynamics.
Related
Japan is bracing for rage against the vending machine
Japan faces vending machine issues due to new banknotes with 3D holograms. 80% of machines need upgrades. Cash remains vital despite cashless trends. Travelers should check bill compatibility during transition.
Let's stop counting centuries
Count centuries as "the 1700s" for clarity, addressing confusion with decades. Language evolution and adapting conventions are crucial. Emphasizes easy language evolution and practical time period references.
Counting Complexity (2017)
Scroll Notation Complexity (SNC) measures entity complexity through tree structures with a symbolic language. It compares Relative and Total Complexity, suggesting SNC for universal complexity comparisons and visualizing complex systems.
The Japanese Way to Multiply Is So Much Cooler Than Ours (2020)
A viral TikTok video has popularized a graphical multiplication method using sticks, often called "Japanese multiplication," which aids visualization but lacks historical documentation compared to traditional techniques.
Colors in Japan
The blog examines Japanese color terminology, focusing on tanzaku cards in hanafuda, the dual meaning of 青 (ao), and the evolution of color vocabulary, highlighting cultural influences on color perception.
Of course, some forms of redundancy would be better than others--in cases where people aren't sure which particle to use, it probably isn't doing much good. However, language evolution is able to achieve some optimizations, and I suspect the particles people know tend to be the most important. For example, the many sushi or shellfish particles might sound particularly silly, but if you're in those industries, maybe they are helpful in maintaining important distinctions in a noisy kitchen/market, or in written records. If you're a customer you probably don't know them, and you don't need to.
Epistemic status: Wild-ass guessing from my armchair.
Like 一本书,两位人 and so on. Yet, you can default to the generic one which is 个 (even if it might not sound very proper or educated, it’s not wrong per say).
素晴らしい着眼点ですね。気付きに感謝します!
The Book of Saint Albans being a prime example of this
Related
Japan is bracing for rage against the vending machine
Japan faces vending machine issues due to new banknotes with 3D holograms. 80% of machines need upgrades. Cash remains vital despite cashless trends. Travelers should check bill compatibility during transition.
Let's stop counting centuries
Count centuries as "the 1700s" for clarity, addressing confusion with decades. Language evolution and adapting conventions are crucial. Emphasizes easy language evolution and practical time period references.
Counting Complexity (2017)
Scroll Notation Complexity (SNC) measures entity complexity through tree structures with a symbolic language. It compares Relative and Total Complexity, suggesting SNC for universal complexity comparisons and visualizing complex systems.
The Japanese Way to Multiply Is So Much Cooler Than Ours (2020)
A viral TikTok video has popularized a graphical multiplication method using sticks, often called "Japanese multiplication," which aids visualization but lacks historical documentation compared to traditional techniques.
Colors in Japan
The blog examines Japanese color terminology, focusing on tanzaku cards in hanafuda, the dual meaning of 青 (ao), and the evolution of color vocabulary, highlighting cultural influences on color perception.