August 8th, 2024

FUTO Warrant Canary

FUTO confirmed its systems' integrity, stating no private keys were disclosed and no classified requests for user information were received. A canary statement will be re-signed in 2025 for transparency.

Read original articleLink Icon
FUTO Warrant Canary

FUTO has confirmed the integrity of its systems, stating that no private encryption keys have been disclosed and that there has been no forced modification of their system to allow unauthorized access or information leakage. The organization has not received any National Security Letters, FISA court orders, or classified requests for user information, nor has it been subject to any gag orders from a FISA court. FUTO plans to re-sign this canary statement on April 20, 2025, and will include a link to a recent news article in each update to verify that the signature was not pre-generated. The last signing occurred on August 8, 2024.

- FUTO asserts that its systems remain secure and have not been compromised.

- The organization has not received any classified requests for user information.

- A canary statement will be re-signed in 2025 to maintain transparency.

- Each update will include a link to a news article for verification purposes.

Link Icon 1 comments
By @tithe - 6 months
I thought these were not considered effective, as their removal effectively violates the gag order?

Update: From 2014, but Moxie Marlinspike comments that "every lawyer we've spoken to has confirmed that [warrant canaries] would not work":

> If it's illegal to advertise that you've received a court order of some kind, it's illegal to intentionally and knowingly take any action that has the effect of advertising the receipt of that order. A judge can't force you to do anything, but every lawyer I've spoken to has indicated that having a "canary" you remove or choose not to update would likely have the same legal consequences as simply posting something that explicitly says you've received something.

https://web.archive.org/web/20141027143819/https://github.co...