Algorithmic price-fixing of rents is here
RealPage's software may enable algorithmic price-fixing among landlords, raising antitrust concerns and impacting housing affordability. Current laws struggle to address this, while legislative updates progress slowly.
Read original articleThe article discusses the potential antitrust implications of RealPage, a company that provides property management software to landlords, which may facilitate algorithmic price-fixing in the rental market. Lawsuits against RealPage allege that its software enables landlords to coordinate rent increases without direct collusion, effectively creating a price-fixing cartel. This situation raises concerns about the impact on housing affordability, as a significant percentage of multifamily units in the U.S. are reportedly priced using RealPage's recommendations. Critics argue that the company's practices, including pressuring landlords to follow its pricing suggestions, resemble cartel behavior. While RealPage disputes these claims, the legal landscape for addressing algorithmic collusion remains challenging. Existing antitrust laws require proof of explicit agreements between companies, which is difficult to establish without access to internal communications or algorithmic data. Some lawmakers are proposing updates to antitrust laws to address these issues, but progress is slow. The article warns that if algorithmic price-fixing goes unchecked, it could lead to a dystopian pricing environment where competition diminishes, resulting in higher costs for consumers and stunted economic growth.
- RealPage's software may facilitate algorithmic price-fixing among landlords.
- Lawsuits claim this practice exacerbates the housing affordability crisis.
- Existing antitrust laws struggle to address algorithmic collusion effectively.
- Legislative efforts to update antitrust laws are currently limited.
- Unchecked algorithmic pricing could harm competition and consumer costs.
Related
Three Algorithms in a Room
Airlines' history of price-fixing led to algorithmic pricing adoption in various sectors. DOJ and FTC pursue lawsuits against algorithmic price-fixing schemes to prevent collusion, impacting future pricing practices.
AI is quietly being used to pick your pocket
AI enables personalized pricing in retail and other sectors based on individual data like age and mood, raising concerns about bias, inflation, and privacy. Calls for regulatory oversight to prevent exploitation are increasing.
FTC launches probe into 'surveillance pricing'
The FTC investigates "surveillance pricing," where AI adjusts prices based on customer data. Eight companies, including Mastercard and JPMorgan Chase, face scrutiny over personalized pricing practices. Concerns about privacy risks are raised.
San Francisco to ban software that "enables price collusion" by landlords
San Francisco's Board of Supervisors approved a ban on software facilitating price collusion among landlords, targeting RealPage and Yardi, amid concerns over rising rents and vacancy rates.
San Francisco Moves to Ban Anti-Competitive Rent Software
San Francisco plans to ban software enabling landlords to collude on rent prices, targeting Yardi and RealPage, to combat automated price-fixing and improve housing affordability amid rising rents.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/19/business/economy/rent-pri...
Its old fashion collusion. Using the word algorithm obfuscates the simplicity in the criminal activity.
Is that part of the legal requirements for a guilty judgement or breaking up a cartel? In the US at least? Would RealPage be fine if they treat their recommended prices as mere suggestions?
I don't control prices. That is supply and demand.
Software that looks at rents in area and suggests a price just sounds like automation of what I do manually.
Related
Three Algorithms in a Room
Airlines' history of price-fixing led to algorithmic pricing adoption in various sectors. DOJ and FTC pursue lawsuits against algorithmic price-fixing schemes to prevent collusion, impacting future pricing practices.
AI is quietly being used to pick your pocket
AI enables personalized pricing in retail and other sectors based on individual data like age and mood, raising concerns about bias, inflation, and privacy. Calls for regulatory oversight to prevent exploitation are increasing.
FTC launches probe into 'surveillance pricing'
The FTC investigates "surveillance pricing," where AI adjusts prices based on customer data. Eight companies, including Mastercard and JPMorgan Chase, face scrutiny over personalized pricing practices. Concerns about privacy risks are raised.
San Francisco to ban software that "enables price collusion" by landlords
San Francisco's Board of Supervisors approved a ban on software facilitating price collusion among landlords, targeting RealPage and Yardi, amid concerns over rising rents and vacancy rates.
San Francisco Moves to Ban Anti-Competitive Rent Software
San Francisco plans to ban software enabling landlords to collude on rent prices, targeting Yardi and RealPage, to combat automated price-fixing and improve housing affordability amid rising rents.