August 12th, 2024

New research on why Cahokia Mounds civilization left

Recent research at Cahokia Mounds suggests the civilization's abandonment around 1400 was due to social factors and external pressures, not drought-induced crop failure, with future studies planned on their agricultural practices.

Read original articleLink Icon
New research on why Cahokia Mounds civilization left

Recent archaeological research at Cahokia Mounds State Historic Site in Illinois has provided new insights into the reasons behind the abandonment of this once-thriving civilization around 1400. Previously, it was widely believed that a prolonged drought led to crop failures, prompting the Cahokians to leave. However, a study by Natalie Mueller and Caitlin Rankin suggests that the inhabitants may have possessed the agricultural skills to adapt to environmental challenges, indicating that social factors and external pressures were more significant in their departure. The research involved analyzing carbon isotopes from soil samples, which showed no drastic changes in plant types that would indicate widespread crop failure. Instead, the consistent ratios of Carbon 12 and Carbon 13 suggest that the Cahokians maintained a diverse diet and effective food storage systems. Mueller proposes that the abandonment was likely a gradual process influenced by various pressures rather than a sudden exodus. Future research aims to further explore the agricultural practices and dietary habits of the Cahokians to better understand their societal dynamics and the factors leading to their decline.

- Cahokia was one of the largest pre-Columbian civilizations in North America, with a population of around 50,000.

- New research challenges the theory that drought-induced crop failure was the primary reason for the civilization's abandonment.

- Isotope analysis indicates that the Cahokians likely adapted their agricultural practices to environmental changes.

- The abandonment process was likely gradual, influenced by social and external pressures rather than a sudden event.

- Future studies aim to gather more data on the agricultural practices of the Cahokians to understand their societal dynamics better.

Link Icon 5 comments
By @_xerces_ - 2 months
Cahokia Mounds are great, but I had to pass through the scariest, sketchiest, most bombed-out looking neighborhoods I have ever seen to get to them. This was 20 years ago, so maybe things are much better now, but I never thought I would see such urban blight and devastation in the USA. It makes me wonder about the civilization that used to live in St. Louis 50 years ago with their grand brick warehouses, industrial might and river boat commerce.

Maybe the population of St. Louis themselves also fits the narrative: “They put a lot of effort into building...but there were probably external pressures that caused them to leave,” Rankin said. “The picture is likely complicated.”

By @westurner - 2 months
I used to live near the Missouri River before it meets the Mississippi River south of STL, but haven't yet made it to the Cahokia Mounds which are northeast and across the river from what is now St. Louis, Missouri.

Was it disease?

["Fusang" to the Chinese, various names to Islanders FWIU]

[?? BC/AD: Egyptian treasure in Illinois, somehow without paddleboats to steam up the Mississippi]

~800 AD: Lead Cross of Knights Templar in Arizona, according to America Unearthed S01E10. https://www.google.com/search?q=%7E800+AD%3A+Templar+Cross%2... ; a more recent dating of Tucson artifacts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tucson_artifacts

~1000 AD: Leif Erickson, L'Anse aux Meadows; Discovering Vinland: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leif_Erikson#Discovering_Vin...

And then the Story of Erik the Red, and a Skraeling girl in Europe, and Columbus; and instead we'll celebrate Juneteenth day to celebrate when news reached Galveston.

Did they plant those mounds? Did they all bring good soil or dirt to add to the mound?

May Pole traditions may be similar to "all circle around the mountain" practices in at least ancient Egyptian culture FWIU.

If there was a lot of contact there, would that have spread diseases? (Various traditions have intentionally high contact with hol y water containers on the way in, too, for example.)

FWIU there's strong evidence for Mayans and Aztecs in North America; but who were they displacing?

By @Bluestein - 2 months
I had the (dubious) honor of - willingly, on a dare - having plunged rolling down the sides of one of the mounds, during a field trip.-

What fun.-

By @pavlov - 2 months
This reminds me to read "Cahokia Jazz", the new novel by Francis Spufford.

He previously wrote "Red Plenty", a brilliant historical fiction about the Soviet economy and cybernetics in a brief moment of post-Stalin optimism.

By @engineer_22 - 2 months
Tl;Dr: they built a flourishing city, and one hypothesis was drought but new research ruled that out, so we have no idea why they left.