August 14th, 2024

My Trial as a War Criminal (By Leo Szilard, Inventor of Nuclear Chain Reaction)

"My Trial as a War Criminal" by Leo Szilard imagines his trial after a U.S. surrender to the Soviets, critiquing wartime moral dilemmas and accountability regarding atomic weapon use.

Read original articleLink Icon
My Trial as a War Criminal (By Leo Szilard, Inventor of Nuclear Chain Reaction)

"My Trial as a War Criminal" is a 1949 short story by physicist Leo Szilard, who was instrumental in the Manhattan Project. The narrative imagines a scenario where Szilard faces a trial akin to the Nuremberg Trials after the United States surrenders to the Soviet Union due to a germ warfare attack. He is given the option to work on scientific projects in the Soviet Union or stand trial for his involvement in the atomic bomb's development. Choosing the latter, Szilard's opposition to the bomb's use is disregarded during the trial, leading to his conviction. The story critiques the moral implications of wartime decisions, as Szilard is allowed to observe the trials of key U.S. officials, including President Truman, who is also convicted for his orders regarding the atomic bomb. The story was later included in Szilard's collection "The Voice of the Dolphins" and has been noted for its influence on discussions about nuclear ethics, particularly in the context of Soviet physicist Andrei Sakharov's opposition to nuclear weapons.

- The story explores the moral dilemmas surrounding the use of atomic weapons.

- Szilard's trial reflects the complexities of accountability in wartime actions.

- The narrative critiques the dismissal of ethical considerations in military decisions.

- It has been recognized as influential in discussions about nuclear ethics and policy.

Link Icon 2 comments
By @eigenvalue - 8 months
I learned about this recently and was surprised that it's not better known. Szilard simply thought through what might have happened if the US lost to the USSR after WW3. He imagined himself being put on trial for his participation in the Manhattan Project, similar to how leading Nazis were prosecuted in the Nuremberg Trials.

You can read the whole thing here (it's only 8 pages long):

https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...

Apparently, some translated samizdat version of this story was smuggled into the USSR and was read by Sakharov (the Russian equivalent to Oppenheimer) and actually changed his opinions about the nuclear testing program they were engaged in.

In general, I feel like Szilard doesn't get the attention he deserves for his huge contributions. That's probably because he really rubbed a lot of people the wrong way, who thought he was rude and egotistical. Fascinating life though-- also check out his refrigerator inventions/patents that he made with Einstein after they heard a sad story of a family dying in their apartment from a leaky old fridge.