August 16th, 2024

Google threatened tech influencers unless they 'preferred' the Pixel

Google's Team Pixel program faced backlash for requiring influencers to exclusively promote Pixel phones, leading to ethical concerns. The clause was removed after criticism, highlighting issues in influencer marketing integrity.

Read original articleLink Icon
Google threatened tech influencers unless they 'preferred' the Pixel

Google's Team Pixel influencer program has come under scrutiny for a new clause that required influencers to showcase the Pixel phone over competitors or risk termination from the program. This stipulation, which was confirmed through screenshots shared by various influencers, stated that participants were expected to feature the Google Pixel device exclusively and that any preference shown for competing brands could lead to the end of their relationship with Google. The backlash from creators was significant, with many expressing concerns about the ethical implications of such demands. Google later acknowledged that the language used in the agreement "missed the mark" and has since been removed. The Team Pixel program, managed by the PR agency 1000heads, is designed to provide early access to Pixel devices for influencers, but the new terms raised alarms about the integrity of tech reviews. Influencers like Adam Matlock and Kevin Nether have since quit the program, citing the exclusivity clause as a threat to their professional integrity. The situation highlights ongoing issues in the influencer marketing landscape, where the lines between genuine reviews and promotional content can often become blurred.

- Google faced backlash for requiring influencers to prioritize Pixel over competitors.

- The controversial clause was removed after creators expressed concerns about ethics.

- Influencers reported feeling pressured to choose between access to products and maintaining integrity.

- The Team Pixel program is distinct from traditional tech review programs.

- The incident reflects broader issues in influencer marketing and review authenticity.

Link Icon 7 comments
By @learningmore - 6 months
“When asked, Google communications manager Kayla Geier told The Verge that “#TeamPixel is a distinct program, separate from our press and creator reviews programs. The goal of #TeamPixel is to get Pixel devices into the hands of content creators, not press and tech reviewers. We missed the mark with this new language that appeared in the #TeamPixel form yesterday, and it has been removed.”

Those terms certainly caused confusion online, with some assuming such terms apply to all product reviewers. However, that isn’t the case. Google’s official Pixel review program for publications like The Verge requires no such stipulations

By @netsharc - 6 months
The first part of the question is formed so weasely. "You acknowledge that you are expected to...".

Sure, I can acknowledge that GOOG is expecting me to do stuff, but other than me acknowledging the request, it's not asking me to fulfill its expectations (yet). Can you acknowledge me saying "Go fuck yourself" to your expectations?

Obviously the second part is less weasely...

By @mensetmanusman - 6 months
Google should sell their phone division to MS.
By @ilrwbwrkhv - 6 months
Lol. Google knows they can't win in hardware, search or AI anymore. Now you will see more and more evil stuff from the once "do no evil" company abusing its monopoly power.
By @bryant - 6 months
BLUF:

* The program seemed intended for influencers of the non-reviewer and non-press variety.

* Nonetheless, a fair number of reviewers were in the program, and the reviewers are the ones who've spoken up about the language.

Google's statement here in essence implies total blindness to the fact that there were tech reviewers in the program ("#TeamPixel is a distinct program, separate from our press and creator reviews programs. The goal of #TeamPixel is to get Pixel devices into the hands of content creators, not press and tech reviewers. We missed the mark with this new language that appeared in the #TeamPixel form yesterday, and it has been removed.").

^^This all makes it look even worse in my opinion.