Praise for Price-Gouging
John H. Cochrane argues that price gouging during crises efficiently allocates resources, incentivizes supply, and criticizes government regulations that worsen shortages, suggesting direct financial assistance as a better alternative.
Read original articleJohn H. Cochrane's article discusses the controversial topic of price gouging, particularly in the context of natural disasters and pandemics. He argues that price gouging, which occurs when prices rise sharply due to increased demand or decreased supply, should be praised rather than condemned. Cochrane distinguishes price gouging from monopolistic practices, asserting that it operates within competitive markets and serves to allocate scarce resources to those who need them most. He contends that higher prices can incentivize suppliers to bring in more goods and help manage demand effectively. Cochrane criticizes government efforts to regulate price gouging, suggesting that such laws can exacerbate shortages and discourage inventory holding. He emphasizes that while the cultural perception of price gouging is negative, it plays a crucial role in economic efficiency. Cochrane also highlights the importance of allowing market mechanisms to function without interference, arguing that moral disapproval of price gouging often leads to misguided policies that ultimately harm consumers. He concludes that rather than imposing price controls, governments should consider direct financial assistance to those affected by high prices.
- Price gouging is seen as a mechanism to allocate scarce resources efficiently during crises.
- Government regulations against price gouging can worsen shortages and reduce supply.
- Higher prices can incentivize suppliers to increase inventory and manage demand.
- Cultural and moral disapproval of price gouging often leads to ineffective policies.
- Direct financial assistance may be a better alternative to price controls.
Related
Coffee: Never Surprise Your Customers
The article stresses the importance of transparent communication in pricing changes to maintain customer loyalty. A gas station's experience with coffee price adjustments and a personal anecdote highlight this, emphasizing managing customer expectations.
Three Algorithms in a Room
Airlines' history of price-fixing led to algorithmic pricing adoption in various sectors. DOJ and FTC pursue lawsuits against algorithmic price-fixing schemes to prevent collusion, impacting future pricing practices.
Bring crypto back to currency
The article critiques the shift of cryptocurrencies from currency to commodity, advocating for controlled inflation, regulated mining costs, and a decentralized marketplace to restore their original purpose and functionality.
Food is more expensive – are US corporate profits to blame?
U.S. food corporations raised prices significantly, resulting in a median profit increase of 51%. Executives acknowledged exploiting inflation, while food prices outpace wage gains, impacting low-income individuals and raising food insecurity concerns.
An admittedly wandering defense of the SSO tax
The "SSO Tax" refers to higher charges for single sign-on features in software, reflecting price discrimination strategies that maximize revenue by segmenting customers based on their willingness to pay.
Additionally so to believe that the government will hand out money so responsively in reaction to natural disasters that there's no reason to limit price gouging as a way of more effectively making sure poor people can buy food immediately after a hurricane. The government can't be trusted to set prices, but can be trusted to give everyone cash immediately after a hurricane knocks out the major road?
There are no good ways to allocate limited resources in the aftermath of natural disasters or similar acute supply shocks. Setting per-party quotas on buying toilet paper isn't perfectly fair, as the article points out, but to me it seems an awful lot more fair than "the rich get everything." As a limited, temporary amelioration of the kind of naked greed that the article admits most people find repugnant, in situations that are rare and have limited impact on the functioning of normal markets, it seems like common sense.
Which just isn't true. If you can only profit on toilet paper once every 100 years due to a pandemic who is going to build a new supply chain for it?
How many new oil refineries got built during the oil shocks?
How many new bottle water plants got build during Hurricane Katrina?
How many new [mh]otels got built after Woodstock II?
A short term shock (price gouging) doesn't cause new entrants.
Only with government interference stopping new suppliers from entering the market (eg. making it illegal to protect your store from looters) can “gouging” persist.
Let the leftist silent downvoting begin!
Related
Coffee: Never Surprise Your Customers
The article stresses the importance of transparent communication in pricing changes to maintain customer loyalty. A gas station's experience with coffee price adjustments and a personal anecdote highlight this, emphasizing managing customer expectations.
Three Algorithms in a Room
Airlines' history of price-fixing led to algorithmic pricing adoption in various sectors. DOJ and FTC pursue lawsuits against algorithmic price-fixing schemes to prevent collusion, impacting future pricing practices.
Bring crypto back to currency
The article critiques the shift of cryptocurrencies from currency to commodity, advocating for controlled inflation, regulated mining costs, and a decentralized marketplace to restore their original purpose and functionality.
Food is more expensive – are US corporate profits to blame?
U.S. food corporations raised prices significantly, resulting in a median profit increase of 51%. Executives acknowledged exploiting inflation, while food prices outpace wage gains, impacting low-income individuals and raising food insecurity concerns.
An admittedly wandering defense of the SSO tax
The "SSO Tax" refers to higher charges for single sign-on features in software, reflecting price discrimination strategies that maximize revenue by segmenting customers based on their willingness to pay.