August 26th, 2024

The Bug in the Computer Bug Story

In 1947, a moth found in a Harvard computer popularized the term "bug," although it predates this incident, with earlier references to faults in machinery dating back to the 19th century.

Read original articleLink Icon
The Bug in the Computer Bug Story

In 1947, engineers at Harvard University discovered a moth trapped in the Mark II computer, which led to the popularization of the term "bug" in computing. The moth was taped into a log book with the note "first actual case of a bug being found," and this incident is often attributed to Grace Murray Hopper, a notable computer scientist. However, the term "bug" predates this event, with references dating back to the late 19th century, including Thomas Edison’s use of the term to describe faults in machinery. The Oxford English Dictionary notes that "bug" referred to defects in machines as early as 1889. The log book's wording suggests that the engineers were already familiar with the term "bug" in its traditional sense, and the incident merely highlighted an actual insect causing a malfunction. The term "debug" was also in use prior to the moth incident, indicating that the language of computing was evolving from existing engineering slang. Despite the folklore surrounding the origin of "bug," it is clear that the term has a longer history in the context of machinery and faults. The narrative surrounding the moth has become a popular legend, overshadowing the term's earlier usage.

- The term "bug" in computing originated from a 1947 incident involving a moth in a Harvard computer.

- "Bug" was used to describe faults in machinery as early as the late 19th century.

- Grace Murray Hopper is often associated with the term, but it predates her involvement.

- The log book suggests familiarity with the term "bug" before the moth incident.

- "Debug" was also used in engineering slang prior to 1947.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @kens - 7 months
Debunking of the bug story as etymological folklore has been going on since at least 1984. Every few years there's another article about it (which is good for the daily 10,000.) The first appears to have been in Byte magazine and then IEEE Annals of the History of Computing in 1984. Followed by American Speech in 1987 and again in IEEE Annals of the History of Computing in 1998.

Links: https://archive.org/details/eu_BYTE-1984-07_OCR/page/n33/mod... https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=4640793 https://doi.org/10.2307/455415 http://ivizlab.sfu.ca/arya/Papers/IEEE/HTML%20Docs/Computer%...

By @drewcoo - 7 months
Bug was clearly part of the lexicon already. Otherwise no one would have written "First actual case of bug being found." And it wouldn't have been so funny.

Pedant "debunking" obvious joke in a JSTOR article is pretty funny in its own right, though. I hope Matthew Wills will explain how chickens don't cross roads next!

By @not2b - 7 months
Grace Hopper joked about finding a literal bug, because "bug" was already a term for a defect at the time. It it weren't, the joke wouldn't make sense. There seems to be widespread confusion about that, leading to people to write "debunking" stories every couple of years.
By @plus - 7 months
I mean, the sentence "The first actual case of a bug being found" implies that "bug" was already being used in the context of a malfunctioning computer. Otherwise, why would they write it?