California legislature passes controversial "kill switch" AI safety bill
California's SB-1047 mandates a "kill switch" for large AI models to enhance safety, facing mixed reactions from experts and business leaders. Governor Newsom must decide by September 30.
Read original articleThe California State Assembly has passed a controversial bill, SB-1047, aimed at enforcing safety standards for large artificial intelligence models. The bill, which received a 45-11 vote in the Assembly and a 32-1 vote in the Senate, requires AI developers to implement a "kill switch" to deactivate models that pose novel threats to public safety, particularly those operating with limited human oversight. While some AI experts, including Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, support the bill as a necessary regulatory measure, others, like Stanford professor Fei-Fei Li, warn it could have unintended consequences, such as stifling innovation and limiting open-source collaboration. Business leaders have also expressed concerns, urging Governor Gavin Newsom to veto the bill, citing potential burdens on compliance and investment. Newsom, who has until September 30 to make a decision, has indicated he is wary of over-regulation but acknowledges the need for some level of oversight as voiced by AI industry leaders. If he vetoes the bill, the legislature could potentially override it with a two-thirds vote.
- California's SB-1047 mandates a "kill switch" for large AI models to enhance safety.
- The bill has garnered both support and criticism from AI experts and business leaders.
- Concerns include potential stifling of innovation and burdensome compliance costs.
- Governor Newsom faces a decision on whether to sign or veto the bill by September 30.
- The legislature could override a veto with a two-thirds majority vote.
Related
Y Combinator, AI startups oppose California AI safety bill
Y Combinator and 140+ machine-learning startups oppose California Senate Bill 1047 for AI safety, citing innovation hindrance and vague language concerns. Governor Newsom also fears over-regulation impacting tech economy. Debates continue.
Can AI Be Meaningfully Regulated, or Is Regulation a Deceitful Fudge?
Governments consider regulating AI due to its potential and risks, focusing on generative AI controlled by Big Tech. Challenges include balancing profit motives with ethical development. Various regulation models and debates on effectiveness persist.
The Conflict of Interest at the Heart of CA's AI Bill
The article discusses Dan Hendrycks, an executive at CAIS and co-founder of Gray Swan, raising concerns about a conflict of interest regarding California's AI safety bill. Hendrycks' dual roles and company's products suggest potential financial benefits.
From sci-fi to state law: California's plan to prevent AI catastrophe
California's SB-1047 legislation aims to enhance safety for large AI models by requiring testing and shutdown capabilities. Supporters advocate for risk mitigation, while critics warn it may stifle innovation.
California Lawmakers Face Backlash over Doomsday-Driven AI Bill
California's Senate Bill 1047 faces backlash for imposing strict AI regulations, with critics arguing it may stifle innovation and research. A coalition of startups opposes the legislation amid shifting regulatory sentiments.
Related
Y Combinator, AI startups oppose California AI safety bill
Y Combinator and 140+ machine-learning startups oppose California Senate Bill 1047 for AI safety, citing innovation hindrance and vague language concerns. Governor Newsom also fears over-regulation impacting tech economy. Debates continue.
Can AI Be Meaningfully Regulated, or Is Regulation a Deceitful Fudge?
Governments consider regulating AI due to its potential and risks, focusing on generative AI controlled by Big Tech. Challenges include balancing profit motives with ethical development. Various regulation models and debates on effectiveness persist.
The Conflict of Interest at the Heart of CA's AI Bill
The article discusses Dan Hendrycks, an executive at CAIS and co-founder of Gray Swan, raising concerns about a conflict of interest regarding California's AI safety bill. Hendrycks' dual roles and company's products suggest potential financial benefits.
From sci-fi to state law: California's plan to prevent AI catastrophe
California's SB-1047 legislation aims to enhance safety for large AI models by requiring testing and shutdown capabilities. Supporters advocate for risk mitigation, while critics warn it may stifle innovation.
California Lawmakers Face Backlash over Doomsday-Driven AI Bill
California's Senate Bill 1047 faces backlash for imposing strict AI regulations, with critics arguing it may stifle innovation and research. A coalition of startups opposes the legislation amid shifting regulatory sentiments.