September 1st, 2024

AirTags key to discovery of Houston's plastic recycling deception

Brandy Deason used AirTags to expose Houston's recycling program, revealing plastic waste sent to an unauthorized facility. The city stockpiled 250 tons of plastic, raising concerns about recycling effectiveness and scrutiny from authorities.

Read original articleLink Icon
FrustrationSkepticismConcern
AirTags key to discovery of Houston's plastic recycling deception

A Houston resident, Brandy Deason, used AirTags to investigate the city's plastic recycling program, which claimed to accept all types of plastic. Doubting the program's efficacy, she placed AirTags in bags of her plastic waste to track their destination. The tracking revealed that nearly all the bags ended up at Wright Waste Management, a facility that is not authorized to store plastic waste and has failed multiple fire inspections. Deason's findings prompted her to contact Houston's Director of Solid Waste Management, Mark Wilfalk, who acknowledged the facility's poor conditions and confirmed that the city had stockpiled around 250 tons of plastic since late 2022 without recycling any of it. Wilfalk stated that the city is awaiting the opening of a sorting facility, Cyclix, which claims to convert plastic waste into recyclable pellets. However, most of these pellets are expected to be melted down for fuel rather than reused, raising concerns about the effectiveness of the recycling program. The situation has drawn scrutiny, with California's Attorney General investigating Cyclix's claims about plastic recycling.

- A Houston resident used AirTags to uncover recycling fraud in the city's program.

- The investigation revealed that plastic waste was sent to an unauthorized facility.

- The city has stockpiled 250 tons of plastic waste without recycling it.

- A sorting facility is expected to open, but most plastic may be turned into fuel instead of being recycled.

- The situation has attracted attention from state authorities regarding the legitimacy of recycling claims.

AI: What people are saying
The comments reflect a range of opinions on plastic recycling and its implications.
  • Many commenters express skepticism about the effectiveness of plastic recycling, viewing it as a flawed system.
  • There are concerns about the environmental impact of plastic waste and the logistics of recycling processes.
  • Some users share similar instances of recycling failures in other regions, indicating a broader issue.
  • Discussion includes the potential for future solutions and the need for reduced plastic consumption.
  • Several comments highlight the political and social dimensions of recycling, questioning its role in consumer behavior.
Link Icon 17 comments
By @2four2 - 6 months
"By contrast, Apple has been an industry leader in reducing its use of plastic. It uses paper for packaging, and metal rather than plastic for its computer line."

Okay

By @langsoul-com - 6 months
Plastic recycling has always been a sham, just one people bought into as a feel good narrative.

Recycling plastic more than once is basically impossible. It's also not a free process, as grinding up plastic creates micro particles that pollute our air and rivers.

The question is whether there's any material that's cheap, malleable and mass produced enough to replace plastic.

By @lotophage - 6 months
Something similar happened in Australia on a large scale. A soft plastic (single use shopping bag) recycling company called REDcycle which partnered with all the major supermarkets was discovered to be just stockpiling it in warehouses. They'd been doing that for about a decade before they were discovered.
By @sschueller - 6 months
In Switzerland we generally only recycle the plastic PET and only drinking bottles (no detergent etc.).

Since most of the trash is burned in Switzerland to produce electricity and municipal heat it doesn't make sense to recycle other plastics.

IMO a bigger focus should be on the additives in plastics and types of plastic that don't burn clean or can't be captured easily instead of banning straws etc.

Other issues such a one time use vapes which end up in the trash containing non removable batteries should be banned before laws like requiring plastic bottle caps being permanently attached.

By @1970-01-01 - 6 months
Almost all plastic is trash. Metal, paper, clean cardboard, and glass are the true recyclables. Always try to recycle those materials.
By @vzaliva - 6 months
At least all this plastic is now stored in one place and did not end up in rivers and landfills yet. There is a still a hope for happy ending of this story.
By @inquist - 6 months
> Wright Waste Management, located in nearby Harris County

Houston is in Harris county…

By @dinoqqq - 6 months
One of the core problems with plastic and their recycling is that plastic doesn't let itself recycle so easily due to the chemical composition. If you have the best recyclable material (e.g. PET), it will only recycle up to 3 to 4 times and even then new plastic is added to guarantee the quality of the recycled plastic. After that, the chemical composition is that much damaged you cannot use it anymore. The second problem is that with the collection of e.g. household recyclable waste, is that there are so many types of plastic in there, that sorting out the "good quality" plastics from the "bad quality" (Single Use Plastics) is a tedious and expensive process. Most of it will be sorted into 1 category, the category where it is used as fuel for energy production. It is burned.

More effective solutions are focussed on avoiding plastics as much as we can. One of the biggest areas to win is looking at the packaging of products.

What's wrong with plastic recycling: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HNWn885qWtU&pp=ygUgcGxhc3RpYyB...

The plastic recycling numbers in the EU: https://circulareconomy.europa.eu/platform/sites/default/fil...

By @iJohnDoe - 6 months
Not surprising. We know China has stopped taking plastic and other stuff from the US.

There was an article similar here on HN where plastics meant to be recycled end up in very odd places. It’s basically sold for pennies and transported to different places where it’s finally just stockpiled as garbage. Strange business of how it changes hands.

By @pimlottc - 6 months
After seeing a number of stories like this, I wonder if shipping and logistics companies will start routinely scanning their cargo for AirTags.
By @tehlike - 6 months
Here's a related data point - something i like to refer to:

Plastic bags vs reusable bags. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/grocery-bag-environmental...

By @spullara - 6 months
This is actually what we should be doing until we can recycle with positive ROI.
By @ars - 6 months
The article has a typo:

"Most will be melted and turned into fuel that is burned, adding to carbon emissions."

That should say "reducing carbon emissions", not adding. Burning plastic for energy is a net reduction in CO2 emission.

By @Simulacra - 6 months
Pretty much all recycling goes to Municipal Waste now since China and Southeast Asia stopped taking our plastic recycling in 2015. The vast majority of recycling programs in America are just vapor.
By @userbinator - 6 months
What is currently waste will be mined in the future. Everything is recycled on a long enough timescale (provided it doesn't leave the Earth.)

Yes, all this "plastics bad chemicals bad" eco-virtue-signaling is stupid. This idiotic paranoia is more destructive to society than anything else. Keeping the masses scared is how they will continue to maintain control.

By @JKCalhoun - 6 months
Hey, guys. I hate to tell you where I put my AirTag that is now pinging at the Soylent Green plant.
By @lotsofpulp - 6 months
The important question is did this Deason person reduce their consumption after finding out? Because the fact that plastic recycling is a political measure to let consumers feel good about consuming has been known for quite a few years now.