September 2nd, 2024

Brazil Court votes unanimously to uphold X ban. Users switch to Threads, Bluesky

Brazil's Supreme Court upheld a ban on Elon Musk's platform X for not appointing a legal representative. Critics call it authoritarian, while users shift to Threads and Bluesky amid controversy.

Read original articleLink Icon
Brazil Court votes unanimously to uphold X ban. Users switch to Threads, Bluesky

Brazil's Supreme Court has unanimously upheld a ban on Elon Musk's social media platform, X, previously known as Twitter. The ban was initiated after Musk failed to appoint a legal representative in Brazil, which Justice Alexandre de Moraes deemed necessary for the platform to operate legally in the country. Chief Justice Luis Roberto Barroso emphasized that companies must comply with local laws. Following the ban, many Brazilian users have migrated to alternative platforms like Meta's Threads and Bluesky, which have reported significant increases in user activity. The Supreme Court's decision has sparked controversy, with critics labeling it as authoritarian and questioning the legality of imposing fines on users attempting to access X via VPNs. The Brazilian Bar Association has called for a review of these sanctions, arguing that due process must be observed. Political figures, including right-wing congressman Nikolas Ferreira, have expressed strong opposition to the ban, framing it as an attack on free speech. Former President Jair Bolsonaro also criticized the decision, claiming it undermines freedom of expression and the confidence of international businesses in Brazil. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva supported the court's ruling, asserting that compliance with Brazilian law is essential for all companies operating in the country.

- Brazil's Supreme Court upheld a ban on Elon Musk's platform X for failing to appoint a legal representative.

- Users are migrating to Threads and Bluesky, leading to record activity on these platforms.

- Critics of the ban argue it is authoritarian and violates due process rights.

- Political figures have voiced strong opposition, framing the ban as an attack on free speech.

- The Brazilian Bar Association is seeking a review of fines imposed on users accessing X via VPNs.

Link Icon 9 comments
By @BadHumans - 8 months
I'm not sure I agree with Brazil wanting to compel platforms to ban accounts and I don't agree with fining people who try to access the service and if Elon is to be believed, I really don't agree with threatening Twitter's legal rep with prison. Elon is also a hypocrite having done the exact thing Brazil is asking for with India and Turkey in the past and he clearly has no problem inventing reasons to ban people who he doesn't like. ElonJet, accounts that campaign for Harris, journalist, etc. Everyone in this situation sucks.
By @brianolson - 8 months
By @MBCook - 8 months
And Madtodon!

Here’s a post from Eugen Rochko on August 31st (2 days ago):

“Aug 10, 10 sign-ups from #Brazil. Aug 28, 152 sign-ups from Brazil. Today, 4.2k sign-ups from Brazil. Portuguese (Brazil) has already entered the list of top 8 active languages for the last 30 days.”

https://mastodon.social/@Gargron/113059113589150365

By @rbanffy - 8 months
Twitter is not a fundamental right, as access to users isn't a right to a company. If the company wants the product to be available, then it should respect local laws the same way it did in Turkey and India.
By @kranke155 - 8 months
Apparently Brazil only asked for Twitter/X to have a local office (so they could be dealt with inside Brazilian law) and ban like 7 accounts.
By @Fidelix - 8 months
These are the only ones that voted:

Flávio Dino (Appointed by Lula) Cármen Lúcia (Appointed by Lula) Cristiano Zanin (Appointed by Lula) Luiz Fux (Appointed by Lula)

By @blastonico - 8 months
Bluesky is decentralized, it's virtually impossible to ban this thing once it gets enough nodes running around the globe.

Not sure if it's better than Twitter for censorship.

By @breadwinner - 8 months
Note that Elon Musk's definition of free speech includes anything that is not outright illegal, including fake news, see links below. I find it disturbing. The world will be better off without X.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/27/us/politics/elon-musk-kam...

https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-grok-ai-fake-elect...

By @breadwinner - 8 months
Meanwhile Musk has become one of the biggest purveyors of fake news:

https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/trump-harris-election...