September 5th, 2024

Proplifting, Plant Piracy, and Dumpster Chocolates

The essay explores the legal and ethical issues of dumpster diving for gourmet chocolates and proplifting plant cuttings, emphasizing respectful practices and the growing concern of plant theft in gardens.

Read original articleLink Icon
Proplifting, Plant Piracy, and Dumpster Chocolates

The essay discusses the controversial practices of "proplifting" and dumpster diving for gourmet chocolates, highlighting the legal and ethical implications of these activities. The author recounts a personal experience of retrieving chocolate from a dumpster behind a gourmet shop, noting that while dumpster diving is legal in many areas, it is often subject to local laws. The piece also delves into proplifting, where individuals take plant cuttings from public or private spaces, often justifying their actions by the large sales volumes of corporate nurseries. The author emphasizes the distinction between theft and acceptable practices, such as taking cuttings from plants that are overhanging public property. The narrative touches on the cultural phenomenon of plant theft, particularly in botanical gardens, where the allure of rare plants can lead to unethical behavior. The essay concludes with advice on how to politely request a cutting from a neighbor's plant, promoting a more respectful approach to acquiring plants.

- Dumpster diving for food, like gourmet chocolates, is legal in many areas but can be restricted by local laws.

- Proplifting, or taking plant cuttings, raises ethical questions, especially regarding theft from public and private gardens.

- Many individuals justify proplifting by citing the large sales volumes of corporate nurseries.

- Plant theft is a growing concern in botanical gardens, driven by the popularity of rare houseplants.

- A respectful approach to acquiring plant cuttings involves asking the owner for permission and offering to propagate a plant in return.

Link Icon 8 comments
By @ZunarJ5 - 7 months
Rules of the Game:

- If it is a big box department store, succulents and others will shed propable things on the ground and in the containers because they do not care for them properly. Take those and feel no guilt. Those usually go straight to the bin.

- If it is a mom-and-pop store, ask a worker, as they may also use those for their stock or they may ask for a tiny fee. Support your locals.

When in doubt, ask. Commercial stores, they do not get paid enough to care.

Happy hunting, future green technothumbs.

By @putzdown - 7 months
I’m missing something. Why would privately propagating an endangered plant be any kind of theft, crime, or immoral action? I get that cutting or tearing off a piece of someone’s plant is wrong, but if the plant has dropped a piece that can be propagated, where is the harm in taking it?
By @Fraterkes - 7 months
I sometimes think it's slightly funny that theres a lot of people who enjoy the aesthetics of anarchism but who also get squeamish about "crimes" that most ordinary people wouldn't worry about (eg picking up a few plant cuttings from the floor of a botanical garden)
By @cardamomo - 7 months
My proplifting code is a bit simpler: I don't take cuttings, but I will pick up loose leaves or other plant parts from the floor, shelf, or wherever they have landed. Succulents in particular will often drop leaves, which can be quite easy to propagate.
By @jasonsb - 7 months
You wouldn't download a plant
By @jakedata - 7 months
The previous owner of my home was gifted a cutting of Franklinia alatamaha by the Arnold Arboretum in Boston. I am now the custodian of an amazing and extremely rare tree.

https://arboretum.harvard.edu/stories/against-all-odds-growi...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklinia

The owner and arboretum both must have known what they were doing when they planted it in my yard because it is thriving and in full flower right now.

By @baerrie - 7 months
I was at the Brooklyn botanical garden a number of years ago and I remember a hirsute old man in a long duster jacket was just walking through the tropical greenhouse we were in casually grabbing handfuls of plants as he walked by and stuffing them in his pockets with no real care in the world.
By @aaron695 - 7 months
If you want a low down why proplifting is perhaps stealing this is an ok video - https://www.tiktok.com/@smithsgardentown/video/7395326610490...

TL;DR

A lot of proplifters are not comfortable at mom and pop stores, but most big name stores get supplied from mom and pop nurseries.

Real people put a lot of effort in suppling plants, they should be rewarded and taking part of a plant off the floor without permission is technically stealing.

I think what annoys people is the attitude it's a 'right' to proplift. Dumpster divers at least put in effort.