September 21st, 2024

Google calls for halting use of WHOIS for TLS domain verifications

Google proposed ending the use of WHOIS data for TLS certificate verification due to security vulnerabilities, suggesting a deadline of November 1, 2024, while some advocate for an extension to April 30, 2025.

Read original articleLink Icon
Google calls for halting use of WHOIS for TLS domain verifications

Google has proposed halting the use of WHOIS data for verifying domain ownership in the issuance of TLS certificates, following a security report by watchTowr that revealed vulnerabilities in the current system. TLS certificates are essential for establishing secure HTTPS connections, and the existing process allows certificate authorities (CAs) to verify domain ownership by sending an email to the address listed in the WHOIS record. However, researchers demonstrated that threat actors could exploit this process by creating a fake WHOIS server, allowing them to obtain certificates for domains they do not own. In response, Google suggested that CAs should not rely on WHOIS data for domain contact identification, with a proposed deadline of November 1, 2024, for this change. While many support the proposal, some, including representatives from Amazon, argue for an extension to April 30, 2025, due to the complexities involved in transitioning away from WHOIS. The discussion is ongoing, and formal voting on the proposed changes has yet to commence.

- Google has called for an end to using WHOIS data for TLS certificate verification due to security vulnerabilities.

- Researchers demonstrated that fake WHOIS servers could be used to fraudulently obtain TLS certificates.

- The proposed deadline for discontinuing WHOIS reliance is November 1, 2024, but some industry representatives suggest extending it to April 30, 2025.

- The CA/Browser Forum is currently discussing the proposed changes, with formal voting yet to begin.

Link Icon 1 comments
By @austin-cheney - 4 months
This only serves to double down on an extremely bad idea. CAs are a form of wealth concentration that is both technically and practically problematic. Finding an alternative to that system is far more ideal than denying public access to DNS registration data, which also only serves as a form of wealth consolidation. DNS name registration is essentially a form of real estate.