"Hygienic" Let Statements in Rust
Remon, a library developer in Rust, faces hygiene issues with macros causing variable shadowing. She opts for a simpler solution to maintain usability while balancing correctness and complexity in software development.
Read original articleRemon, a dedicated library developer, is focused on creating stable and flexible libraries in Rust. She emphasizes automated testing and thorough documentation in her work. In her exploration of Rust macros, she encounters a challenge with hygiene in her macro definition, specifically regarding variable shadowing. Her initial macro, designed to simplify user input handling, inadvertently allows for conflicts with constants in the caller's scope, leading to potential silent bugs. After discussions with her friend Wolfie, who points out the hygiene issue, Remon attempts various solutions, including using pattern matching to avoid conflicts. However, these solutions introduce new complications, such as compilation errors when constants are present. Ultimately, Remon decides against overly complex solutions that require extensive documentation and additional code, opting instead for a slightly less hygienic approach that maintains usability without excessive overhead. This decision reflects her understanding of practical software development, balancing correctness with maintainability.
- Remon is a responsible library developer focused on stability and flexibility in Rust.
- She encounters hygiene issues in her macro that can lead to silent bugs due to variable shadowing.
- Various attempts to resolve the issue introduce new complications, including compilation errors.
- Remon ultimately chooses a simpler, less hygienic solution to maintain usability and reduce complexity.
- The narrative highlights the balance between correctness and practical software development challenges.
Related
I Hope Rust Does Not Oxidize Everything
The author expresses concerns about Rust's widespread adoption in programming, citing issues with syntax, async features, complexity, and long compile times. They advocate for language diversity to prevent monoculture, contrasting Rust with their language Yao.
Tonsky: Don't go crazy with Clojure unless it makes you happy
The author shares their journey using Clojure macros for Humble UI's component library, emphasizing the language's flexibility in enabling unconventional solutions like reading source files and fetching code seamlessly.
Clojure macros continue to surprise me
The author shares their journey using Clojure macros for Humble UI's component library, creating a macro to display running code alongside its source. Despite challenges, they find Clojure's flexibility rewarding for experimentation.
Quote-unquote "macros"
The blog post examines macros in the Janet programming language, highlighting their advantages over traditional memoization, particularly in compile-time storage allocation and the significance of quoting and unquoting in macro development.
The weird of function-local types in Rust
The article examines function-local types in Rust, highlighting accessibility issues, macro complications, and potential workarounds. It emphasizes careful design to prevent compilation errors and documentation test failures.
Related
I Hope Rust Does Not Oxidize Everything
The author expresses concerns about Rust's widespread adoption in programming, citing issues with syntax, async features, complexity, and long compile times. They advocate for language diversity to prevent monoculture, contrasting Rust with their language Yao.
Tonsky: Don't go crazy with Clojure unless it makes you happy
The author shares their journey using Clojure macros for Humble UI's component library, emphasizing the language's flexibility in enabling unconventional solutions like reading source files and fetching code seamlessly.
Clojure macros continue to surprise me
The author shares their journey using Clojure macros for Humble UI's component library, creating a macro to display running code alongside its source. Despite challenges, they find Clojure's flexibility rewarding for experimentation.
Quote-unquote "macros"
The blog post examines macros in the Janet programming language, highlighting their advantages over traditional memoization, particularly in compile-time storage allocation and the significance of quoting and unquoting in macro development.
The weird of function-local types in Rust
The article examines function-local types in Rust, highlighting accessibility issues, macro complications, and potential workarounds. It emphasizes careful design to prevent compilation errors and documentation test failures.