Crypto Wars: Hungarian Presidency continues fight against encryption
The Hungarian Presidency of the EU Council is advocating for strategic encryption solutions, including a "front door" data request method, while addressing civil rights concerns and enhancing counter-terrorism cooperation.
Read original articleThe Hungarian Presidency of the EU Council is advocating for a strategic approach to address encryption challenges, as outlined in a draft document from the Council. This initiative stems from the work of the EU High-Level Expert Group on Data Access for Effective Law Enforcement (HLEG), which aims to facilitate access to metadata and communication data from end-to-end encrypted services like WhatsApp and Signal. Belgium's Federal Police is proposing a "front door" method for law enforcement to request data directly from service providers without requiring back doors. The EU Commission plans to develop a roadmap for implementing these strategies, emphasizing the need for effective data access to combat crime. However, civil rights activists have raised concerns about potential overreach and the implications of such measures, warning against extreme decisions made without public scrutiny. The Hungarian government is also pushing for a comprehensive counter-terrorism agenda, enhancing cooperation among member states and addressing threats from disinformation and radicalization. Additionally, the EU is working on integrating various databases for security and border management, which could lead to the creation of a biometric super database. This ongoing effort reflects the EU's commitment to balancing security needs with fundamental rights.
- The Hungarian Presidency is pushing for a strategic approach to encryption issues in the EU.
- Belgium proposes a "front door" method for law enforcement data requests.
- Civil rights activists warn against extreme measures taken without public input.
- The EU aims to enhance cooperation on counter-terrorism and information sharing.
- Plans for a biometric super database are part of broader security and border management efforts.
Related
EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control
The EU Council withdrew the vote on Belgium's Chat Control plan due to lack of support. Critics raised privacy concerns over monitoring chat messages and client-side scanning. Uncertainty looms as discussions resume post-summer.
EU cancels vote on private chat app law amid encryption concerns
The European Union cancels vote on law targeting child sexual abuse material over encryption concerns. Proposed measures involve scanning images on messaging apps, sparking privacy debates among member states. Negotiations ongoing.
Europol says Home Routing mobile encryption feature aids criminals
Europol raises concerns about criminals using Home Routing mobile encryption to avoid interception. Proposes disabling encryption or implementing a cross-border interception mechanism to streamline investigations and balance privacy with law enforcement.
Danish Justice Minister Under Fire for Pushing Encryption Ban While Using It
Danish Justice Minister Peter Hummelgaard faces criticism for advocating a ban on encrypted messaging apps while using them himself, amid calls for transparency from parliament members also utilizing these services.
New EU push for chat control: Will messenger services be blocked in Europe?
The EU is proposing a bill to monitor private messages for illegal content, risking encryption and prompting opposition from platforms like Signal, while critics warn of privacy violations and ineffectiveness.
It feels like, even if they win this battle in the crypto wars, the real battleground has actually moved on anyway.
As an aside, that recent "Ghost Chat" infiltration[0][1] that apparently took down a few international crime gangs, wouldn't a Matrix / Synapse server and clients be a better option for encrypted communications than a custom phone/app?
[0]: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-09-17/afp-raids-ghost-app-f...
Well, if you give the government too much power, sooner or later they will become the child abusers and terrorists. And at that point, there will be no police you can really call, since those in power will be able to act with absolute power and absolute impunity.
Related
EU Council has withdrawn the vote on Chat Control
The EU Council withdrew the vote on Belgium's Chat Control plan due to lack of support. Critics raised privacy concerns over monitoring chat messages and client-side scanning. Uncertainty looms as discussions resume post-summer.
EU cancels vote on private chat app law amid encryption concerns
The European Union cancels vote on law targeting child sexual abuse material over encryption concerns. Proposed measures involve scanning images on messaging apps, sparking privacy debates among member states. Negotiations ongoing.
Europol says Home Routing mobile encryption feature aids criminals
Europol raises concerns about criminals using Home Routing mobile encryption to avoid interception. Proposes disabling encryption or implementing a cross-border interception mechanism to streamline investigations and balance privacy with law enforcement.
Danish Justice Minister Under Fire for Pushing Encryption Ban While Using It
Danish Justice Minister Peter Hummelgaard faces criticism for advocating a ban on encrypted messaging apps while using them himself, amid calls for transparency from parliament members also utilizing these services.
New EU push for chat control: Will messenger services be blocked in Europe?
The EU is proposing a bill to monitor private messages for illegal content, risking encryption and prompting opposition from platforms like Signal, while critics warn of privacy violations and ineffectiveness.