October 7th, 2024

Google Will Track Your Location 'Every 15 Minutes'–'Even with GPS Disabled'

Google's Pixel 9 Pro XL tracks user data every 15 minutes, even with GPS off, sending sensitive information to Google without user consent, raising significant privacy and security concerns.

Read original articleLink Icon
Google Will Track Your Location 'Every 15 Minutes'–'Even with GPS Disabled'

A recent report by Cybernews reveals that Google's Pixel 9 Pro XL smartphone tracks user location and other data every 15 minutes, even when GPS is disabled. The research team conducted tests on a new device with default settings, finding that it sends data packets to Google, including location, email address, phone number, and network status. This data is transmitted to various Google services, raising concerns about user privacy and consent. Notably, the phone estimates location using nearby Wi-Fi networks when GPS is turned off. The report also highlights that the device communicates with Google services, such as the Photos app, without explicit user consent. Additionally, the phone attempts to download and execute new code, which could pose security risks. While the data collection may be necessary for certain features, the lack of transparency and potential privacy violations are alarming. The findings suggest that users may be unaware of the extent of data being shared and the implications for their privacy. Google has been approached for comments regarding these findings, but the report underscores broader concerns about surveillance within Google's ecosystem.

- Google's Pixel 9 Pro XL tracks user data every 15 minutes, even with GPS disabled.

- The device sends sensitive information, including location and personal details, to Google servers.

- Communication with Google services occurs without explicit user consent.

- The phone attempts to download new code, raising potential security risks.

- The findings highlight significant privacy concerns regarding data collection practices.

Link Icon 9 comments
By @techcode - 5 months
Simply being connected to mobile (or wifi) network is enough to get your location - sometimes with pretty good precision.

So if you're worried about NSA or the like - you better not have a mobile phone/device (or a car - because new cars sold in EU all have eSIM for builtin emergency calls) at all.

And for particular first hand example - Xplora smart watch/phone got super confused when my kids school physically moved.

New building has indoor sports/gym (I think it's basketball court size) on the top floor - and all the reinforced concrete means mobile reception can be hit and miss (even on 3/4G).

Despite phone/watch never connecting to school (staff only) wifi. After move to new building - watch and parent app would regularly think/bounce location between old and new school buildings.

When even 3rd party companies have a mapping between wifi/ssid and approximate geo location, you can imagine state sponsored actors have at least next order of magnitude.

By @prophesi - 5 months
I imagine this isn't the case if you're running GrapheneOS on it? I think it would be safe to assume that the factory defaults on any Android would be phoning home whether it's Google, Samsung, or what have you.
By @xd1936 - 5 months
Disingenuous article. The headline should be "Google Location Tracking is on by default in a brand new Google account and I don't like that".

https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/3118687

By @readthenotes1 - 5 months
I installed duck duck goes application tracking protection utility and was mind boggled at how many apps were tracking my location, battery level, etc on a regular and ongoing basis without notification because it is all through 3rd party ad networks.

Even more concerning where the apps, like AT&t's and Fidelity, that do it just to make the money by reselling the data, not to show ads.

By @vibrant_mclean - 5 months
Trying to be private ironically just going to make it worse and make you stand out. Using a non-default OS, non-default browser, custom settings/blocklists will just make your fingerprint more unique.

I use an android phone but just don't use any other google services - no search, no gmail, no default apps. I do most browsing in tor-browser, so google ads won't correlate with me.

By @Circlecrypto2 - 5 months
Where is the investment into a real smart phone that protects your privacy. I'd pay a premium for this, especially if the manufacturing and resources used fair labor.
By @dotnet00 - 5 months
Is the location they're referring to supposed to be just the country code field in that screenshot?
By @asimpleusecase - 5 months
So will the EU fine them for violation of GDPR?