The Pettiest Drama in the Tech World Is Taking Place at... WordPress?
Matt Mullenweg criticized WP Engine for exploiting WordPress, leading to a cease-and-desist letter and a lawsuit from WP Engine against Mullenweg and Automattic, raising concerns about conflicts of interest.
Read original articleMatt Mullenweg, co-founder and CEO of Automattic, has engaged in a public dispute with WP Engine, a major client that utilizes WordPress' open-source code for its hosting services. The conflict began when Mullenweg criticized WP Engine during WordCamp U.S., accusing it of exploiting WordPress without adequately contributing to the ecosystem. He specifically targeted Silver Lake, the private equity firm that owns WP Engine, suggesting it prioritizes profit over open-source values. This led to a series of aggressive statements from Mullenweg, including a call for the WordPress community to withdraw support from WP Engine. In response, WP Engine sent a cease-and-desist letter, alleging that Mullenweg threatened to launch a public campaign against them unless they paid a significant sum to Automattic. The situation escalated with Mullenweg announcing WP Engine's ban from the WordPress nonprofit network, which was later temporarily lifted after backlash from users. The dispute has raised concerns about Mullenweg's dual role in both the commercial and nonprofit aspects of WordPress, leading to accusations of conflicts of interest. WP Engine has since filed a lawsuit against Mullenweg and Automattic, claiming extortion and other serious allegations, while Automattic has dismissed the lawsuit as meritless.
- Matt Mullenweg publicly criticized WP Engine for not supporting the WordPress ecosystem adequately.
- WP Engine responded with a cease-and-desist letter, alleging threats from Mullenweg.
- The conflict has raised concerns about Mullenweg's dual role in WordPress' commercial and nonprofit sectors.
- WP Engine has filed a lawsuit against Mullenweg and Automattic, claiming extortion and defamation.
- The situation highlights tensions between open-source ideals and corporate interests in the tech industry.
Related
WordPress Drama: From the Sidelines
Tensions between WP Engine and Automattic escalated into a legal dispute after Matt Mullenweg criticized WP Engine's contributions, leading to revoked API access and concerns about WordPress's future.
The messy WordPress drama, explained
Matt Mullenweg criticized WP Engine for exploiting the WordPress ecosystem, leading to legal threats and access restrictions for its customers, while the community remains divided over the implications for WordPress's future.
Mullenweg threatens corporate takeover of WP Engine
Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg has revoked an 8% licensing deal with WP Engine, criticizing its contributions to WordPress and hinting at a takeover, while WP Engine has responded with legal action.
Matt Mullenweg: 'WordPress.org just belongs to me'
Matt Mullenweg asserts control over WordPress and is in a lawsuit with WP Engine over trademark infringement and inadequate support, raising concerns about the impact on the open-source community.
Mullenweg has gone 'nuclear' against tech investing giant Silver Lake
Matt Mullenweg is involved in a legal dispute with Silver Lake regarding WP Engine's trademark violations and contributions to WordPress, with lawsuits filed by both parties raising concerns about open-source commercialization.
Why should opensource maintainers be expected to act altruistically in this scenario? Parasitic behavior poisons goodwill in opensource communities, and prevents future innovation and effort.
Related
WordPress Drama: From the Sidelines
Tensions between WP Engine and Automattic escalated into a legal dispute after Matt Mullenweg criticized WP Engine's contributions, leading to revoked API access and concerns about WordPress's future.
The messy WordPress drama, explained
Matt Mullenweg criticized WP Engine for exploiting the WordPress ecosystem, leading to legal threats and access restrictions for its customers, while the community remains divided over the implications for WordPress's future.
Mullenweg threatens corporate takeover of WP Engine
Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg has revoked an 8% licensing deal with WP Engine, criticizing its contributions to WordPress and hinting at a takeover, while WP Engine has responded with legal action.
Matt Mullenweg: 'WordPress.org just belongs to me'
Matt Mullenweg asserts control over WordPress and is in a lawsuit with WP Engine over trademark infringement and inadequate support, raising concerns about the impact on the open-source community.
Mullenweg has gone 'nuclear' against tech investing giant Silver Lake
Matt Mullenweg is involved in a legal dispute with Silver Lake regarding WP Engine's trademark violations and contributions to WordPress, with lawsuits filed by both parties raising concerns about open-source commercialization.