October 31st, 2024

How Google Is Killing Bloggers and Small Publishers – and Why

Bloggers and small publishers face challenges due to Google's algorithm changes and AI-generated answers, which reduce traffic. The author suggests treating web searches as a public utility to ensure fairness.

Read original articleLink Icon
How Google Is Killing Bloggers and Small Publishers – and Why

The article discusses the challenges faced by bloggers and small publishers due to Google's evolving search algorithms and business practices. Initially, the author shares their journey of starting a travel blog, learning about Search Engine Optimization (SEO), and adapting their content to meet Google's requirements. However, recent changes, particularly the "Helpful Content Update" and the introduction of AI-generated answers, have drastically reduced traffic to small blogs. The author highlights that Google has shifted its focus from being a search engine to becoming a dominant advertising platform, which has led to a significant decline in visibility for independent content creators. The partnership between Google and Reddit, which allows Google to utilize Reddit's content for its AI, further exacerbates the issue by directing traffic away from individual blogs. The author expresses concern over the future of blogging and suggests that web searches should be treated as a public utility to prevent monopolistic practices.

- Google's algorithm changes have significantly harmed small publishers and bloggers.

- The introduction of AI-generated answers in search results has reduced traffic to independent blogs.

- Google is increasingly prioritizing advertising revenue over organic content.

- The partnership with Reddit allows Google to leverage user-generated content, further disadvantaging small publishers.

- The author advocates for treating web searches as a public utility to ensure fair access to information.

Link Icon 14 comments
By @will-burner - 6 months
An assumption of the article is that in addition to getting readers, bloggers want to make money from their blogs via advertising, brand endorsements, etc. That's fair and true for the author in this case, but not necessarily true of all bloggers, especially the tech type that are on hacker news.
By @Nekhrimah - 6 months
The axiom: AI allows wealth to access skill, while denying skill access to wealth, ringing especially loud from this story.
By @janalsncm - 6 months
I have a small blog. I don’t run it for money and I like to tell myself I’m the only audience that matters. (It’s not entirely false, I frequently check it to reference how to do something.) But I empathize with people trying to navigate the shifting waters of the Google algorithm.

One thought I had: is there any plugin to rerank Google results by the number of ads on a site? For the top 10,000 domains we could count the average number of ads on a page and give each one an “annoyingness score” which would be used to downrank spammy garbage.

By @not_your_vase - 6 months

  > Oh, and by the way, here’s how you can ditch Google and switch to DuckDuckGo.
The closing sentence is... well... seems futile?

DDG is Bing, and if you say that Google is all about AI-generated crap, then Bing turns it up to 11...

(Don't read it as schadenfreude. I couldn't be more depressed about it)

By @rybosworld - 6 months
It really is a shame how bad the quality of google search results has gotten. The user experience today feels adversarial.
By @Scoundreller - 6 months
> You may have noticed, sometime around September 2023 that your Google search results were starting to include a whole lot of Reddit. And a bunch of Quora. For those of you who love Reddit, great. It can be a valuable tool. For those of you who prefer to get information from verified sources it became just another result to skip over.

I guess everyone has the same feelings about Quora and there isn’t even a need to waste the characters on calling them out.

By @Scoundreller - 6 months
> This was back in 2014, when a Google search result looked very very different than it does now. We were gaining traction and we wanted more. We saw the possibilities and it was a red-hot inspiration. Our dreams of being like the travel bloggers we looked up to seemed possible.

I’m impressed they even managed to become successful travel bloggers in 2014+.

SEO and being a travel blogger were both well trodden paths already.

I remember some friends saying they wanted to become travel bloggers ~2013 and I laughed because of the degree of saturation. Was already difficult to get an edge and a niche.

And in my experience, Google was well on its path of deranking blogs in favour of more corporate content in 2014.

By @NemoNobody - 6 months
It's all built on advertising revenue. The blogs & their rise and fall - all based on ad revenues that Google created as they perverted the Internet to make everything content a platform for the advertising - all with the willing and complicit support of the bloggers and content creators.

I don't see advertising on the Internet so I don't really understand the value. Some people use Google to access the Internet apparently... they see lots of ads.

By @octacat - 6 months
It is not just google, people "prefer video content" like instagram's CEO says. So, some traffic lost because people just find the same stuff on tiktok/ig. Oh, and accidentality google has youtube.

But the main issue is that just googling stuff and checking the results is a pretty miserable experience, because of quality of search results (they would give you CEO optimized trash 90%).

By @lofaszvanitt - 6 months
DuckDuckGo and Bing is the same cesspool. People need to wake the fuck up and support each other instead of these behemoths.
By @nb2 - 6 months
I think we need decentralized search engines because big companies control too much of what we see.
By @christkv - 6 months
I have started using chatgpt to generate my searches as it does a better job than me.
By @xnx - 6 months
Reminder that Google owes you nothing. No one is entitled to free traffic from Google.