Runtime-Extensible SQL Parsers Using Peg
Traditional SQL parsers are outdated and inflexible, while modern PEG parsers enable dynamic syntax changes and better error handling. A prototype demonstrates efficiency, emphasizing the need for updated parser technology.
Read original articleThe article discusses the limitations of traditional SQL parsers in data management systems, which often rely on outdated technologies like YACC. These parsers are inflexible and hinder innovation due to their monolithic design. The authors advocate for a shift towards modern Parsing Expression Grammars (PEG), which allow for dynamic changes to query syntax and improved error recovery. PEG parsers can be reconfigured at runtime, enabling the integration of new syntax and features without the need for extensive recompilation. This flexibility is particularly beneficial as SQL specifications evolve and new query languages emerge. The authors present a prototype PEG parser that successfully parses SQL queries and demonstrate its extensibility through experiments. Although the PEG parser shows a performance slowdown compared to traditional methods, the absolute parsing times remain efficient for analytical queries. The article emphasizes the need for modernizing parser infrastructure to enhance user experience and support the growing complexity of SQL dialects. The findings will be presented at the 2025 Conference on Innovative Data Systems Research (CIDR).
- Traditional SQL parsers are outdated and inflexible, limiting innovation.
- Modern PEG parsers allow for dynamic syntax changes and better error handling.
- A prototype PEG parser has been developed, demonstrating extensibility and efficiency.
- Despite some performance trade-offs, PEG parsers maintain acceptable parsing times for analytical queries.
- The research highlights the importance of updating parser technology in data management systems.
Related
Pipe Syntax in SQL
GoogleSQL enhances SQL by introducing a piped data flow syntax, improving usability and learning while maintaining compatibility with existing systems, allowing for gradual adoption of new features.
Is Text-to-SQL Dead? The Past, Present, and Future of AI-Powered Analytics
Text-to-SQL systems are evolving to improve response times and accuracy by using data templates, reducing latency significantly, and focusing on enhancing filtering techniques to meet user demands for actionable insights.
I love Rust for tokenising and parsing
The author develops a Rust-based static analysis tool for SQL, sqleibniz, focusing on syntax checks and validation, utilizing macros for code efficiency, and plans to implement an LSP server.
Why I love Rust for tokenising and parsing
The author develops sqleibniz, a Rust-based static analysis tool for SQL, focusing on syntax checks and validation. Future plans include creating a Language Server Protocol server for SQL.
SQL, Homomorphisms and Constraint Satisfaction Problems
The article highlights SQL's ability to solve complex problems like Sudoku and CSPs, demonstrating efficiency in puzzles compared to Python and C, and its relationship with graph theory and homomorphisms.
- tech $X is from the 60s, therefore it is bad and/or outdated: one doesn't need to "disrupt" or innovate in everything to become modern. There are plenty of things from the 60s that still don't have a better replacement, and its OK to keep using it.
- "YACC-style parsers" clumps together parsers that are generated at compile-time, from declarative grammars, using LALR(1). But that's not inherit to the technique or algorithm: a parser can be LALR(1) from a declarative grammar and still extensible at run-time, or provide LL(1) alongside, or be built from statements instead of a grammar. There's nothing wrong with using PEGs over "YACC-style" parsers, but not for these distorted reasons.
In particular, Microsoft SQL Server seems to do everything just a little bit differently, and sqlparser-rs does support its idiosyncrasies most of the time.
Related
Pipe Syntax in SQL
GoogleSQL enhances SQL by introducing a piped data flow syntax, improving usability and learning while maintaining compatibility with existing systems, allowing for gradual adoption of new features.
Is Text-to-SQL Dead? The Past, Present, and Future of AI-Powered Analytics
Text-to-SQL systems are evolving to improve response times and accuracy by using data templates, reducing latency significantly, and focusing on enhancing filtering techniques to meet user demands for actionable insights.
I love Rust for tokenising and parsing
The author develops a Rust-based static analysis tool for SQL, sqleibniz, focusing on syntax checks and validation, utilizing macros for code efficiency, and plans to implement an LSP server.
Why I love Rust for tokenising and parsing
The author develops sqleibniz, a Rust-based static analysis tool for SQL, focusing on syntax checks and validation. Future plans include creating a Language Server Protocol server for SQL.
SQL, Homomorphisms and Constraint Satisfaction Problems
The article highlights SQL's ability to solve complex problems like Sudoku and CSPs, demonstrating efficiency in puzzles compared to Python and C, and its relationship with graph theory and homomorphisms.