December 13th, 2024

Hospitals gave patients meds during childbirth, then reported them for drug use

Hospitals in the U.S. report women to child welfare after positive drug tests from childbirth medications, raising concerns about wrongful accusations and the need for policy reforms to protect families.

Read original articleLink Icon
Hospitals gave patients meds during childbirth, then reported them for drug use

In recent investigations, it has been revealed that hospitals across the U.S. are reporting women to child welfare authorities after they test positive for drugs that were administered during childbirth. Medications such as morphine, fentanyl, and benzodiazepines, routinely given for pain relief or anxiety management, have led to positive drug tests in newborns and mothers. This practice has raised concerns about the criminalization of pregnant women, particularly in the wake of increased surveillance since the overturning of Roe v. Wade. Cases like that of Amairani Salinas, who was reported after receiving midazolam during an emergency cesarean, and Victoria Villanueva, who tested positive for morphine given during labor, illustrate the distressing consequences of these policies. Many hospitals lack adequate protocols to review patient medication histories before making reports, leading to wrongful accusations and the potential removal of children from their parents. Experts argue that the current system is flawed, with many healthcare providers lacking the necessary training to interpret drug tests accurately. The situation highlights the urgent need for policy reform to protect birthing individuals from undue scrutiny and to ensure that medical practices do not inadvertently harm families.

- Hospitals report women to child welfare after positive drug tests from medications administered during childbirth.

- Medications like morphine and benzodiazepines, commonly used for pain relief, often trigger these positive results.

- Increased surveillance of pregnant women has led to fears of criminalization and wrongful accusations.

- Many hospitals lack protocols to review medication histories before reporting, resulting in potential harm to families.

- Experts call for policy reforms to protect birthing individuals and improve medical practices regarding drug testing.

Related

Black mothers in England twice as likely to have NHS birth investigated

Black mothers in England twice as likely to have NHS birth investigated

Black mothers in England face significant disparities in maternity care, with investigations showing they are almost twice as likely to be involved compared to white women. Experts label it a "national disgrace" due to institutional racism. The Care Quality Commission's program has conducted over 2,300 investigations into maternal and neonatal issues. Black women are four times more likely to die in pregnancy and childbirth, prompting calls for urgent action to address racial inequalities in maternity care. The Labour government vows to prioritize improvements in this area.

She Ate Poppy Seed Salad Just Before Giving Birth. Then They Took Her Baby Away

She Ate Poppy Seed Salad Just Before Giving Birth. Then They Took Her Baby Away

Susan Horton tested positive for opiates after consuming a poppy seed salad, leading to her newborn's removal. Urine drug screens can yield false positives, disproportionately affecting low-income and minority women.

Nursing Homes Overuse 'Chemical Restraints' on Dementia Patients

Nursing Homes Overuse 'Chemical Restraints' on Dementia Patients

Nursing homes in the U.S. overprescribe antipsychotics to over 21% of residents, often without proper diagnoses, raising health risks and concerns about care quality amid staffing shortages and ineffective regulations.

Higher maternal mortality rates in states with more abortion restrictions

Higher maternal mortality rates in states with more abortion restrictions

A Tulane University study found that restrictive abortion policies correlate with higher maternal mortality rates, suggesting that reducing such restrictions could improve women's health and lower maternal death rates.

Hospitals gave patients meds during childbirth, then reported them for drug use

Hospitals gave patients meds during childbirth, then reported them for drug use

Hospitals in the U.S. face criticism for reporting mothers to child welfare after positive drug tests from medications given during childbirth, prompting calls for reform to prioritize patient care.

Link Icon 13 comments
By @joe_the_user - 4 months
So they tested the kid's bowel movements for drugs and reported the parent for drugs they themselves gave. On the surface, it seems like a "right hand not knowing what the left hand is doing" but such things always going to happen when a system is used for both care and enforcement.

And as the article mentions, the outlawing of abortion in some states has accelerated these problems.

By @gnabgib - 4 months
Inexplicably no discussion, but popular yesterday (44 points) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42404691
By @Fire-Dragon-DoL - 4 months
If you sued for mental damage the state for such a thing, would you be able to win?

It says a child was taken from the mum for 5 months, that's an impossible damage, literally to get back to something similar you need another child + 9 months + all the costs associated to having 2 children (and career progression loss).

By @aftbit - 4 months
Dum dum dum dumb.

Classic "not my problem" case in health care. Clinician 1 gives a typical medication to patient, then their shift ends and they go home. Hours or days later, clinician 2 administers a drug test as part of standard process, then their shift ends and they go home. Clinician 3 then reviews this positive test result and reports it to authorities as part of a mandatory reporting program. Nobody acts as a patient advocate and reviews the full case file. Everyone just does their one transactional piece and forgets the entire history ten seconds later in favor of doing another transactional thing for another patient.

By @Aloisius - 4 months
It sounds like the justice system is what's broken.
By @underseacables - 4 months
It feels like today, mothers face increasing danger going into hospitals. The medical professionals have so much power and control over you when you're there, and one mistake can kill you or ruin your life. There really needs to be greater patient protections.
By @SuperNinKenDo - 4 months
A case study in the banality of evil sadly. Also a perfect example of why care and enforcemrnt should never be mixed, both for its immediate effects and the lasting distrust it will eventually cause.
By @OutOfHere - 4 months
The state government has too much power to define what a mother can or can't do. It doesn't deserve such power. Using it correctly or not is a whole other consideration.
By @ortusdux - 4 months
It's recommended to avoid poppy seeds during the last few months of pregnancy to avoid false positives.
By @christophilus - 4 months
Is it normal to give morphine to mothers during childbirth? That seems crazy to me.
By @stuaxo - 4 months
So dystopian.