December 16th, 2024

Why the Past 10 Years of American Life Have Been Uniquely Stupid

American society has fragmented over the past decade, largely due to social media fostering outrage and division, weakening social capital, and threatening democratic health by amplifying trivial conflicts.

Read original articleLink Icon
Why the Past 10 Years of American Life Have Been Uniquely Stupid

The article discusses the fragmentation of American society over the past decade, likening it to the biblical story of Babel, where communication breakdown leads to disunity. The author, Jonathan Haidt, argues that social media has played a significant role in this disintegration by fostering environments that prioritize outrage and division over constructive dialogue. Initially, social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter were seen as tools for connection and democratization. However, after 2009, the introduction of features that encouraged virality transformed these platforms into arenas where emotional responses, particularly anger, became the primary currency. This shift has weakened social capital, eroded trust in institutions, and disrupted shared narratives that are essential for a cohesive society. The article suggests that the mechanisms designed to enhance user engagement have inadvertently deepened societal divides, making it increasingly difficult for Americans to communicate and collaborate across ideological lines. The author warns that this trend poses a significant threat to the health of democracy, as it amplifies trivial conflicts and diminishes the capacity for collective action.

- The past decade has seen a significant fragmentation of American society, likened to the story of Babel.

- Social media has shifted from a tool for connection to a platform that amplifies outrage and division.

- Features encouraging virality have weakened social capital and trust in institutions.

- The transformation of social media dynamics has made it harder for Americans to communicate across ideological divides.

- This trend poses a serious threat to the health of democracy by magnifying trivial conflicts.

Link Icon 7 comments
By @cainxinth - 4 months
By @DonnyV - 4 months
This whole article sounds like the US Administrative State complaining they can't control the narrative anymore because all of their "institutions" have been found to be fronts for elites.
By @naming_the_user - 4 months
I definitely agree with the idea that social media has created a bunch of "odd" groups and a ton of division, but sometimes I wonder what the alternative is.

It seems like prior to social media we had mass media and that served as basically the forcing function, there was a more national concept of shame.

Nowadays the concept of social shaming doesn't really work because you have competing factions with belief systems that are so far apart that all you really get is shaming "within the group".

By @mbfg - 4 months
The crazy part of the babel myth is that it tells a store of what seems like the first time in human history where people of all backgrounds came together, lived in peace, made technological progress, and god couldn't stand that, as it wanted the people dumb, scared and fractured.

It seems the pattern keeps repeating to today.

By @Suppafly - 4 months
And they are going to continue to be stupid going forward as well :(
By @anovikov - 4 months
"If you really give people what they want, and give them ability to communicate what they want, bad things happen"
By @dialup_sounds - 4 months
tl;dr - social media