December 19th, 2024

Towards a new kind of science and technology

The article emphasizes thermodynamics' role in modern science, advocating for practical experimentation to explore undiscovered laws in non-equilibrium thermodynamics and self-organizing systems for future advancements.

Read original articleLink Icon
Towards a new kind of science and technology

The article discusses the significance of thermodynamics and electricity in the development of modern science and technology. It highlights how thermodynamics, which governs the conversion of heat into usable power, has been fundamental to advancements in chemistry and engineering. The author reflects on the historical context of thermodynamics, noting that its principles emerged from practical observations rather than abstract theories. The piece critiques the reductionist approach often taught in schools, suggesting that this perspective may limit understanding of thermodynamics' broader implications. The author posits that there are undiscovered laws within non-equilibrium thermodynamics and emphasizes the need for further exploration of self-organizing systems, which could yield practical applications. The discussion also touches on the historical contributions of figures like Onsager and Haken, who sought to unify various phenomena through thermodynamic principles. Ultimately, the author argues for a return to practical experimentation and observation to unlock new insights in thermodynamics and related fields.

- Thermodynamics is crucial for converting heat into usable power and has shaped modern chemistry and engineering.

- The historical development of thermodynamics was driven by practical observations rather than abstract theories.

- There are likely undiscovered laws in non-equilibrium thermodynamics that warrant further investigation.

- Self-organizing systems may hold the key to understanding complex behaviors in matter and could lead to practical applications.

- A focus on practical experimentation is necessary to advance knowledge in thermodynamics and related scientific fields.

Link Icon 3 comments
By @Yusefmosiah - 4 months
I feel like I'm in a parallel universe where Stephen Wolfram doesn't exist. But he does, he's a living legend, and his seminal work, A New Kind of Science, and its core concepts, computational equivalence and computational irreducibility, are the answers you're looking for here.

For more up-to-date thoughts on thermodynamics I'd start here: https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/computational-fo...

By @Animats - 4 months
Ambitious title.

The key idea seems to come from this 1995 paper.[1] Here's a later paper.[2] None of them get far enough to tie this to real world experimental results, It's all descriptive math at this point, as the original article points out. But maybe someday someone will make further progress and understand turbulence or something.

Anybody understand this?

[1] https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1995RvMP...67..605R/abstra...

[2] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1408.5443

By @TheCleric - 4 months
Overly aggressive use of the term “computard” is at best unserious and at worst deeply offensive.