December 31st, 2024

Brian Eno: AI's Walking Dog

Brian Eno's essay critiques AI's profit-driven motives, warning of societal harms, emphasizing intentionality in creativity, expressing mixed feelings about AI in art, and questioning society's discernment of AI-generated information.

Read original articleLink Icon
Brian Eno: AI's Walking Dog

Brian Eno's essay "AI’s Walking Dog" critiques the current trajectory of artificial intelligence, emphasizing the importance of ownership and intent behind AI technologies. He argues that the profit-driven motives of companies lead to outcomes that prioritize speed and market share over social value and security. Eno draws parallels between the development of AI and the pitfalls of social media, warning that the same profit-maximizing strategies could result in negative societal impacts. He highlights the significance of the creative process, noting that AI often lacks intentionality and provenance, which diminishes the value of its outputs. Eno expresses mixed feelings about using AI in artistic endeavors, finding it both intriguing and tedious, as it often feels like a hollow experience devoid of genuine learning. He suggests that while AI can assist artists in recognizing patterns, it requires careful prompting and filtering to yield meaningful results. Ultimately, Eno questions whether society will be as discerning about the information produced by AI as it is about the food it consumes, urging a more thoughtful engagement with the technology.

- Eno critiques the profit-driven motives behind AI development, warning of potential societal harms.

- He emphasizes the importance of intentionality and provenance in the creative process.

- Eno expresses mixed feelings about AI's role in art, finding it both useful and unsatisfying.

- The essay draws parallels between AI and the negative impacts of social media.

- Eno questions society's discernment regarding AI-generated information compared to food consumption.

Link Icon 3 comments
By @nunez - 4 months
I didn't expect Brian Eno, of all people, to so beautifully sum up how I feel about AI.

I especially resonated with his statements on AI not being developed by the public. Meta, Microsoft, Tesla and, by proxy, some venture capitalists being the only entities capable of financing and spear-heading AI development is extremely problematic. This is exactly like the cable and telephone companies of yesteryear attempting to lay claim the early Internet. Our world would look very different had the Internet been a private Gambit from the start.

Not like any of this matters. AI is being force-fed to us like an "airplane" of broccoli heading for a baby's mouth, societal and cultural impacts be damned. Too much money to be made.