February 7th, 2025

The Government's Computing Experts Say They Are Terrified

Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency seeks access to U.S. government IT systems, raising concerns among experts about potential catastrophic breaches and disruptions to critical services due to untrained personnel.

Read original articleLink Icon
The Government's Computing Experts Say They Are Terrified

Elon Musk's recent efforts to access U.S. government data and information systems through his newly established Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) have raised significant concerns among federal IT professionals. Experts warn that Musk's actions could lead to unprecedented breaches of critical systems that manage essential government functions, such as financial transactions and air traffic control. They describe the situation as potentially the largest IT security breach in U.S. history, with fears that untrained personnel could inadvertently or deliberately compromise sensitive data. Reports indicate that DOGE has sought access to various federal agencies, including the Treasury and the FAA, with some members allegedly given inappropriate access levels. The complexity and interconnectedness of government IT systems mean that even minor disruptions could have catastrophic consequences, including halting payments or endangering air travel safety. Experts emphasize that the lack of experience among DOGE staff poses a significant risk, as they may not fully understand the systems they are attempting to modify. The situation is exacerbated by the fact that Musk's team may not have the necessary security clearances or expertise to navigate these intricate infrastructures safely. As the situation unfolds, the potential for severe damage to government operations and public safety remains a pressing concern.

- Musk's DOGE is attempting unprecedented access to U.S. government IT systems.

- Experts warn of potential catastrophic consequences from untrained personnel accessing critical infrastructure.

- The situation is described as possibly the largest IT security breach in U.S. history.

- Concerns include disruptions to essential services like financial transactions and air traffic control.

- The complexity of government systems increases the risk of severe operational failures.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @xnx - 2 months
At what point will we have to assume that any systems touched by doge are compromised/backdoored?
By @Terr_ - 2 months
I imagine this would be like if my company got a new temporary CEO, paid purely in cash, with a 4-year visa and diplomatic immunity from his home country.

And then he brings in a bunch of "old associates" who run around demanding all the master passwords, 2FA recovery codes, and even access to change the audit logs... or else you'll be fired.

Meanwhile, some others are gleefully talking about how their superior fresh outsider perspective will allow them to seamlessly replace That Big Old System that nobody likes but which if it vanishes the company can't serve customers or can't pay bills or gets lawsuit'ed into oblivion.

> The contractor emphasized that nobody yet knows which information DOGE has access to, or what it plans to do with it.

The most-charitable I can possibly go on this is that it will be Twitter all over again [0]: They will cherry-pick records, leak access to hand-picked pieces, and lie they've found the Loch Ness Monster of Somebody Else Being Bad, trusting that not enough people will have the inclination/access/time to check before it becomes "a fact" in supporters' minds.

[0] https://www.techdirt.com/2025/02/03/the-twitter-files-playbo...

By @rapsey - 2 months
Government experts have a rather poor track record when arguing some point in the media.