June 21st, 2024

Tonight with the Impressionists

A virtual reality experience, "Tonight with the Impressionists," set in 1874 Paris, offers a detailed but flawed exploration of the first Impressionist exhibition. Issues with collisions and spatial inconsistencies hinder immersion.

Read original articleLink Icon
Tonight with the Impressionists

Tonight with the Impressionists is a virtual reality experience set in Paris, 1874, where visitors explore the first exhibition by Impressionist artists. The experience allows participants to walk around a room filled with other people, creating a unique but potentially frustrating encounter due to collisions and spatial inconsistencies. Despite the detailed virtual environment and narration, issues like walking into non-existent spaces and encountering ghostly outlines of other visitors detract from the immersion. The focus on physical movement as a means to enhance immersion ultimately leads to safety concerns and detracts from appreciating the artwork. The experience's attempt to heighten immersion through ambulation falls short, resulting in a stressful and potentially disorienting encounter. The pricing, length, and technical challenges of the experience raise questions about its overall value and effectiveness in delivering a memorable exploration of Impressionist art.

Link Icon 2 comments
By @gergo_barany - 4 months
I was in Paris in March and had a ticket for this. I was at the museum an hour before my booked time slot. The square in front of the entrance was one gigantic queue, and when I asked at the front I was told that they were still processing people who had booked a time slot an hour before that. I decided not to stand around in the rain for two hours for a very dubious chance to get what I had paid for. There are no refunds for any reason ever, of course.

It's a shame because when I lived in Paris the Musée d'Orsay was one of my favorites. Apparently management changed sometime in the last few years, and ticket sales are higher than ever. But only because it has turned into yet another tourist trap.

By @davedx - 4 months
I visited a small museum near where I live the other day (The Kröller-Müller Museum, in the Netherlands), the founder happened to pick up quite a few Van Gogh paintings over her collecting, including one of my favourites (Terrasse du Café le Soir), but also a lot of other incredible works by him. One of the things that stood out to me is how the oil is so thickly layered in some paintings. It's most obvious in Cypresses and Two Women -- the painting is so rich with oil paint (so I guess it was done in a period when he could afford plenty of materials) the trees all have a ridged texture to them.

It's just another dimension to his art, but it really grabbed me. It's not something that would be easy to replicate in a VR exhibition, I don't think.