SCOTUS Rules That US Government Can Continue Talking to Social Media Companies
The Supreme Court allows US government to communicate with social media companies, overturning an injunction. Court finds lack of evidence for direct censorship injuries. Decision may increase government-platform interaction.
Read original articleThe Supreme Court has ruled in a 6–3 decision that the US government can continue communicating with social media companies, overturning an injunction that had prevented such interactions for over a year. The case, brought by the attorneys general of Louisiana and Missouri, alleged that government agencies influenced content moderation practices on platforms, leading to the removal of conservative-leaning content. However, the court found that the plaintiffs did not provide enough evidence to prove direct censorship injuries resulting from government communications with social media companies. The ruling emphasized that platforms often exercise independent judgment in content moderation. Experts note the importance of government-platform communication in disseminating accurate information to users, such as voting locations or emergency procedures. The decision is seen as potentially opening the door for increased government involvement with platforms, regardless of political affiliations. Google and Meta declined to comment on the case.
Related
TikTok confirms it offered US Government a 'kill switch'
TikTok offered a "kill switch" to the US government amid data protection concerns. Legal disputes continue as ByteDance faces pressure to sell TikTok's US assets by January to avoid a ban.
Internet Archive forced to remove 500k books after publishers' court win
The Internet Archive removed 500,000 books due to a court ruling favoring publishers. The organization is appealing, arguing for fair use. Supporters stress the impact on education and access to information.
Google: Stop Burning Counterterrorism Operations
Google's Project Zero and TAG exposed a U.S.-allied government's counterterrorism operation, sparking debate on the impact of revealing such information. Cyber operations play a crucial role in counterterrorism efforts, balancing intelligence gathering with minimizing risks.
TikTok confirms it offered US Government a 'kill switch'
TikTok offered a "kill switch" to the US government amid data security concerns. Legal battles persist over potential divestment from ByteDance. Reports suggest data sharing between TikTok and ByteDance.
I Study Disinformation. This Election Will Be Grim.
Renée DiResta warns about the surge in election disinformation in the US, fueled by false claims of the 2020 election being stolen. She stresses the need to combat misinformation despite facing backlash and threats. The Stanford Internet Observatory had to adjust its focus due to pressures.
SCOTUS didn't rule anything of the sort; they didn't get to the merits of the case. They dismissed the claim for lack of standing:
"We begin--and end--with standing. At this stage, neither the individual nor the state plaintiffs have established standing to seek an injunction against any defendant. We therefore lack jurisdiction to reach the merits of the dispute."
But how weird would it be if there was an industry segment the federal government was not allowed to talk to? The whole complaint seems like a thinly veiled attempt to say the federal government is not actually a government.
It's good to know the Fediverse at large (and Mastodon in particular) make this easier than ever. Perhaps this entire concern can be made moot by further adoption of decentralized technologies.
Related
TikTok confirms it offered US Government a 'kill switch'
TikTok offered a "kill switch" to the US government amid data protection concerns. Legal disputes continue as ByteDance faces pressure to sell TikTok's US assets by January to avoid a ban.
Internet Archive forced to remove 500k books after publishers' court win
The Internet Archive removed 500,000 books due to a court ruling favoring publishers. The organization is appealing, arguing for fair use. Supporters stress the impact on education and access to information.
Google: Stop Burning Counterterrorism Operations
Google's Project Zero and TAG exposed a U.S.-allied government's counterterrorism operation, sparking debate on the impact of revealing such information. Cyber operations play a crucial role in counterterrorism efforts, balancing intelligence gathering with minimizing risks.
TikTok confirms it offered US Government a 'kill switch'
TikTok offered a "kill switch" to the US government amid data security concerns. Legal battles persist over potential divestment from ByteDance. Reports suggest data sharing between TikTok and ByteDance.
I Study Disinformation. This Election Will Be Grim.
Renée DiResta warns about the surge in election disinformation in the US, fueled by false claims of the 2020 election being stolen. She stresses the need to combat misinformation despite facing backlash and threats. The Stanford Internet Observatory had to adjust its focus due to pressures.