June 28th, 2024

Surprise the Latest 'Comprehensive' US Privacy Bill Is Doomed

The American Privacy Rights Act (APRA), a bill aiming to establish a federal consumer privacy framework, faced opposition and was pulled from a hearing. Stripped of civil rights protections, its fate remains uncertain.

Read original articleLink Icon
Surprise the Latest 'Comprehensive' US Privacy Bill Is Doomed

The American Privacy Rights Act (APRA), a comprehensive privacy bill, was pulled from a congressional hearing, signaling its likely demise. The bill, stripped of civil rights protections to appeal to pro-business Republicans, faced opposition from both parties. The proposed legislation aimed to establish a federal consumer privacy framework, requiring corporations to handle private data responsibly. However, the bill's removal from consideration highlights the ongoing struggle to regulate commercial surveillance practices in the US. The decision to cancel the hearing came after House GOP leaders expressed intentions to derail the bill, regardless of committee approval. The bill's revisions, which omitted key civil rights protections and transparency measures, led to widespread criticism and loss of support from major privacy and civil liberties groups. The failure to pass such legislation perpetuates the unregulated monitoring of individuals' data by corporations, impacting critical aspects of their lives. Despite efforts to address data privacy and surveillance issues, the fate of comprehensive privacy legislation in the US remains uncertain.

Link Icon 2 comments
By @blackeyeblitzar - 4 months
We need these protections immediately, not 30 years from now. How do we start a movement that builds awareness of the degree of digital tracking and surveillance everyone is subject to?
By @openrisk - 4 months
The political dysfunction in the US means that a critical design feature of a digital economy, namely what data about individual behavior gets collected, passed around, merged and acted upon gets obscured by various interests.

Eg., pro-privacy is portrayed as "anti-business" when in fact the opposite is true. Creating masses of digital homeless people that have no "digital real estate" because whatever value in their digital footprints is immediately confiscated is not exactly the road to riches.

Extrapolating 'privacy is dead' means bank privacy (and financial privacy more general) is dead - somebody will always be frontrunning you and stealing any of your potential wealth. It also means that health privacy is dead (somebody can and will exploit your physical condition for their own gain) etc.

The logical conclusion is the segregation of society into hordes of data-transparent non-entities at the bottom and a minority of data-opaque overlords on top.

All in all an absurd, exploitative, deeply anti-human system that can only be compared to a regression to a slave society. It may yet come to pass and "flurish", to the extend that it can suppress the inherent instability of such an arrangement.