July 2nd, 2024

Waymo got pulled over. What happens next in Phoenix?

A Waymo autonomous vehicle in Phoenix was briefly in the wrong lane due to construction signage issues. Police couldn't cite the driverless car. Waymo emphasizes safety features and Arizona's autonomous vehicle testing environment.

Read original articleLink Icon
Waymo got pulled over. What happens next in Phoenix?

In Phoenix, a Waymo autonomous vehicle was pulled over by a police officer after driving into oncoming traffic and running a red light. The vehicle encountered construction signage issues, leading it into the wrong lane for about 30 seconds. The police were unable to issue a citation to the driverless car. Waymo vehicles are equipped to sense emergency vehicles and can unlock doors and roll down windows when stopped. First responders can communicate with operators through an intercom or a dedicated phone number. Passengers are advised to cooperate with police and follow instructions from the operator. Arizona has approved around a dozen autonomous vehicle companies for testing. While self-driving cars offer mobility benefits, safety concerns persist, with incidents prompting investigations and regulatory actions. Waymo claims its data shows autonomous vehicles have fewer accidents than human drivers. Other companies like Cruise and Uber have faced challenges with safety regulations and incidents in Arizona.

Link Icon 7 comments
By @cbanek - 5 months
"unable to issue citation to computer" is about the stupidest and laziest police response I have ever heard. I am beyond upset about this. It's obvious they could issue a citation and send it to the address on the registration of the car, which is certainly Waymo or a company that could forward it to Waymo.

If my parked car gets a ticket, they put it on the windshield. It's not some stupid response like "unable to issue citation to car with no one in it." Since the window was open, they could also tape it on the dash or put it on the driver's seat.

There is no reason why Waymo should not get a citation and be forced to appear in court to explain themselves, just like everyone else. That is why the courts exist. But lazy cops seem to prevent this from happening.

By @cthalupa - 5 months
I'm fairly skeptical on driverless cars but it's hard to say what the deal is here - I see plenty of humans end up in the wrong lane around construction zones, too. Obviously we want these things to be better than humans, but it'd be nice to know if this was just the sort of mistake we see humans commonly make here, or if it was egregious.

Dashcam footage of what the car actually did would be pretty helpful in understanding what actually happened.

By @simple10 - 5 months
Unless I missed something, there's no clarity in the article about whether or not Waymo eventually got issued a citation. But I also couldn't watch the full video without being bombarded by ads and audio that started running headless in the background.
By @renewedrebecca - 5 months
Tickets are supposed to be a deterrent to violating traffic laws. For a corporation though, even a big ticket is just a drop in the bucket. Laws will need to be updated if these things are allowed to be on the streets.
By @LorenPechtel - 5 months
The fundamental problem of AI cars--they have a set of rules rather than common sense. They will fare far worse than humans when given impossible directions.
By @1123581321 - 5 months
How is the in-car audio call between Waymo and the police initiated? I would want it to automatically initiate shortly after being pulled over. That would be easiest for emergency services. It would also assure for the passenger and be a way to give the passenger instructions, if needed. The downside would be cost to Waymo to staff a potentially unnecessary call.
By @kyleee - 5 months
Can’t wait for the first felony/high risk stop executed against a waymo, should lead to some good body cam footage (and hopefully nobody gets shot)