July 3rd, 2024

School Smartphone Bans Are Picking Up Steam

Schools globally ban smartphones to combat mental health issues linked to social media. Surgeon General suggests social media warning labels akin to tobacco regulation. Debate surrounds bans' effectiveness versus teaching responsible phone use.

Read original articleLink Icon
School Smartphone Bans Are Picking Up Steam

Schools worldwide are increasingly implementing bans on smartphones in classrooms due to concerns about the negative impact of social media on young people's mental health. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy advocates for warning labels on social media platforms, likening them to the regulation of tobacco products. The bans aim to address issues such as distraction, cyberbullying, and the addictive nature of technology. While some experts argue for teaching responsible phone use instead of outright bans, the move to restrict cell phones in schools is gaining traction globally. Proponents believe these measures are necessary to protect minors from potential harm caused by excessive screen time and addictive technologies. The comparison between smartphones and social media to the historical context of tobacco raises questions about the ethical implications of exposing young individuals to potentially harmful digital environments. By implementing these bans, schools aim to create a healthier learning environment and conduct further research on the effects of technology on students' well-being and academic performance.

Related

Dr. Vivek Murthy: Social media is a key driver of our youth mental health crisis

Dr. Vivek Murthy: Social media is a key driver of our youth mental health crisis

Dr. Vivek Murthy, Surgeon General, warns about social media's negative impact on youth mental health. Urges warning labels on platforms to address mental health crisis and advocates for increased awareness and support.

Los Angeles Unified School District will ban cellphones from school day in 2025

Los Angeles Unified School District will ban cellphones from school day in 2025

The Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) plans to ban student cellphone and social media use during school hours from 2025 to address technology's impact on youth mental health. The decision aligns with statewide efforts to reduce distractions and conflicts in schools. Input from various stakeholders will shape the policy, with concerns raised about enforcement and effectiveness. Some schools report positive outcomes from similar bans, enhancing student engagement and social interactions. LAUSD aims to cater to diverse student needs, including those with disabilities.

California's Gov. Newsom wants to restrict smartphone usage in schools – AP News

California's Gov. Newsom wants to restrict smartphone usage in schools – AP News

California Governor Gavin Newsom plans to limit smartphone use in schools to address mental health concerns linked to social media. This aligns with a national debate, including Surgeon General's call for warning labels. Local control and regulations are advocated.

Schools Can Help End the Phone-Based Childhood

Schools Can Help End the Phone-Based Childhood

Schools address phone overuse by implementing phone-free policies, collaborating with peers, and involving parents. Initiatives like the "Wait Past 8th Pledge" aim to promote healthier tech habits and benefit students.

Can a law make social media less 'addictive'?

Can a law make social media less 'addictive'?

New York passed laws to protect children on social media: SAFE for Kids Act requires parental consent for addictive feeds and limits notifications; Child Data Protection Act restricts data collection. Debate ensues over enforceability and unintended consequences.

Link Icon 3 comments
By @robobro - 5 months
My schools had bans on cell phones, music players, game machines ~20 years back. Teachers would confiscate any gadgets or toys students used in class time, maybe sending them to the office to be reclaimed at the end of the day. When did this stop being a thing?
By @hilbert42 - 5 months
I've long since left school but I'm pretty certain that if I'd had a smartphone at school it would have been a disruptive distraction.

Even leaving aside social media (which I don't use) there are just too many interesting on the internet to hold my interest to ever get bored. I reckon even using a smartphone for school projects would be fraught with distractions, the futzing around just finding relevant info would be time-wasting.

By @vibrio - 5 months
FWIW, I’m seeing a trend in parents getting pre teen kids smart watches rather than phones , allowing calls/texts/location tracking without the social media and internet access. I’m assuming those are outside of the trending school bans? They were not mentioned in the article,