July 4th, 2024

Journalism has become ground zero for the vocation crisis

Journalism industry faces layoffs, burnout, and news deserts impacting civil society. Economic pressures deter talent from vital professions like journalism, nursing, teaching, and caregiving. Challenges highlight clash between ideals and commercial realities.

Read original articleLink Icon
Journalism has become ground zero for the vocation crisis

Journalism has faced a challenging year with significant layoffs in major news outlets, leading to burnout among reporters and editors who are leaving the profession. The shrinking press corps not only impacts civil society but also contributes to the rise of "news deserts," limiting access to reliable local journalism and hindering informed decision-making and political engagement. The industry's struggles reflect broader societal issues, as economic pressures deter people from pursuing socially important careers like journalism, nursing, teaching, and caregiving. Journalism, in particular, faces stagnant pay, job insecurity, longer hours, and demands for less socially valuable content. Despite these challenges, many still find journalism appealing due to its intrinsic rewards beyond monetary compensation. However, the disillusionment and dissatisfaction among journalists, nurses, and teachers highlight the clash between idealized perceptions of these vocations and the commercial realities they face. The persistence in these professions underscores the ongoing struggle to find meaning and fulfillment in work amid market-driven pressures, raising concerns about the future sustainability of vocations in society.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @vandyswa - 5 months
This is a textbook case of "limited hangout":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_hangout

It argues that journalism has a problem--just like everybody else.

Journalism specifically has a crisis because, as an industry, they have spent far too much of their credibility in service to narrative. A tainted product sheds customers, and here you are.

By @GlibMonkeyDeath - 5 months
The vocation crisis in journalism is being driven by economics. Papers sold classified ads, broadcast television sold commercial spots, and this was profitable because it was difficult to replicate the distribution systems (as in the music industry.) Now the FAANG companies have captured the ad revenue because they own the distribution, and those companies (so far) don't seem interested in investing in quality journalism.

This is unlike the entertainment industry, where Amazon and Netflix have become content producers to some extent. They did this because they realized they could get more money by creating entertainment content.

By @patrick451 - 5 months
The public's trust in journalism has cratered because they became activists instead of journalists. It's fascinating and telling that the article avoids this issue completely, not mentioning trust once.