July 8th, 2024

What's the deal with the blue "robins" in gacha games?

The article analyzes the portrayal of blue "robins" in gacha games like Honkai: Star Rail and Fate/Grand Order. Rodrigo Brincalepe Salvador explores the mislabeling of bird species, attributing it to design, geography, and potential lack of ornithological expertise. The piece advocates for appreciating the variety of birds in nature.

Read original articleLink Icon
What's the deal with the blue "robins" in gacha games?

The article discusses the presence of blue "robins" in gacha games, specifically focusing on characters in Honkai: Star Rail and Fate/Grand Order. The author, Rodrigo Brincalepe Salvador, examines the choice of bird species represented in the games' artwork, highlighting discrepancies between the depicted birds and actual robins. While the European robin is traditionally known as a robin, various other bird species, including bluebirds and thrushes, have been inaccurately labeled as robins in these games. Salvador speculates on the reasons behind these choices, suggesting they may stem from a combination of design preferences, geographical considerations, and possibly a lack of ornithological knowledge among game developers. The article concludes by encouraging readers to observe and appreciate the diverse bird species present in their surroundings.

Related

Why blue animals are so rare

Why blue animals are so rare

Blue animals are rare due to the difficulty of producing a true blue pigment. Some creatures, like the electric blue tarantula and blue lobsters, achieve their blue appearance through unique structural features. Blue in nature is limited by light physics and energy needs, but it can aid in attracting pollinators.

Five common English words we don't know the origins of–including 'boy' and 'dog'

Five common English words we don't know the origins of–including 'boy' and 'dog'

The article explores the mysterious origins of English words like "bird," "boy," "girl," "dog," and "recorder." Linguists face challenges tracing their roots, revealing intriguing insights into language evolution.

PigeonBot Uses Real Feathers to Explore How Birds Fly

PigeonBot Uses Real Feathers to Explore How Birds Fly

Stanford University researchers created PigeonBot, a flying robot with biohybrid wings using real feathers to mimic bird flight. The study uncovers feather interactions and flight techniques, aiming to inspire aerospace innovation.

Crows and Magpies Snatch Anti-Bird Spikes to Build Their Nests

Crows and Magpies Snatch Anti-Bird Spikes to Build Their Nests

Crows and magpies in Europe repurpose anti-bird spikes for nesting, showcasing intelligence and adaptability. Birds use spikes for protection and structural support, despite potential drawbacks. Researchers highlight birds' resourcefulness in urban environments.

'Annoyed' Seagulls Are Waging War on NYC's Beach Drones

'Annoyed' Seagulls Are Waging War on NYC's Beach Drones

The presence of police drones on New York City beaches has caused distress among local bird species, leading to defensive behaviors and concerns for endangered populations. The NYPD's drone program faces criticism.

Link Icon 3 comments
By @Freak_NL - 8 months
Like Chinoiserie in the 18th century, with this cultural borrowing — in this case, of a bird found across most of Europe — the designers using these symbols are not engaged in, or particularly renowned for, presenting an accurate portrayal. These design elements are used to invoke a certain otherness (in this case Englishness, presumably) for an audience comprised of only a tiny minority of ornithologists. That is, the mostly Japanese audience likes the striking blue bird and the word 'robin', and wouldn't know a European robin if it landed right in front of them — the only reason I do, as someone who knows nothing of most birds, is that they visit my garden in Europe.

The illustrator likely just found that the blue bird just looked better in their sketches.

By @harimau777 - 8 months
I wonder if there could be different cultural associations at play with the FGO robin. I associate Robin Hood with woodsiness and therefore with colors like browns and greens. So a bright blue bird looks out of place to me while a mostly brown robin would not. Perhaps there is something cultural that blue might seem like less of an odd choice to someone from Japanese culture?
By @Dalewyn - 8 months
FGO is good civilization.