July 8th, 2024

Eton bans smartphone for new pupils

Eton College bans smartphones for new pupils, providing basic Nokia handsets instead to address concerns about negative impacts on behavior and mental health. Other schools also tighten smartphone rules.

Read original articleLink Icon
Eton bans smartphone for new pupils

Eton College has implemented a ban on smartphones for new pupils, opting to issue them with basic Nokia handsets instead. The prestigious private school, known for educating Princes William and Harry, aims to address concerns regarding the negative impact of smartphones on children's behavior and mental health. The new policy requires 13-year-old boarders to transfer their SIM cards to offline Nokia devices that only allow calls and texts. Eton's deputy head emphasized the potential challenges associated with smartphone use, highlighting issues such as overuse and its effects on socialization and health. Other private schools are also tightening smartphone regulations, with some prohibiting internet access on phones for younger students. In St Albans, a group of headteachers has advocated for delaying smartphone ownership until age 14, citing concerns about addiction and exposure to harmful content. The move reflects a growing trend among educators and parents to address the risks associated with early smartphone use and prioritize children's well-being and development.

Related

Los Angeles Unified School District will ban cellphones from school day in 2025

Los Angeles Unified School District will ban cellphones from school day in 2025

The Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) plans to ban student cellphone and social media use during school hours from 2025 to address technology's impact on youth mental health. The decision aligns with statewide efforts to reduce distractions and conflicts in schools. Input from various stakeholders will shape the policy, with concerns raised about enforcement and effectiveness. Some schools report positive outcomes from similar bans, enhancing student engagement and social interactions. LAUSD aims to cater to diverse student needs, including those with disabilities.

California's Gov. Newsom wants to restrict smartphone usage in schools – AP News

California's Gov. Newsom wants to restrict smartphone usage in schools – AP News

California Governor Gavin Newsom plans to limit smartphone use in schools to address mental health concerns linked to social media. This aligns with a national debate, including Surgeon General's call for warning labels. Local control and regulations are advocated.

Schools Can Help End the Phone-Based Childhood

Schools Can Help End the Phone-Based Childhood

Schools address phone overuse by implementing phone-free policies, collaborating with peers, and involving parents. Initiatives like the "Wait Past 8th Pledge" aim to promote healthier tech habits and benefit students.

School Smartphone Bans Are Picking Up Steam

School Smartphone Bans Are Picking Up Steam

Schools globally ban smartphones to combat mental health issues linked to social media. Surgeon General suggests social media warning labels akin to tobacco regulation. Debate surrounds bans' effectiveness versus teaching responsible phone use.

Dumbification of Our Smartphones

Dumbification of Our Smartphones

The article discusses "Dumbification" in technology, where screens become overwhelming. It explores using "dumbphones" and minimalist apps to reduce screen time, emphasizing balance and reclaiming attention in a tech-driven world.

Link Icon 6 comments
By @gnicholas - 3 months
I was recently talking with a student at the small college I went to a couple decades ago and he said that many students go to a different, nearby college to party on the weekends. This was very surprising because we tended to look down on that college — our primary rival — when I was in school, and we never would have gone there to party. The student said the parties weren't much better, but that they wanted to avoid the possibility of doing something stupid and having it show up on social media that all their friends see.

I suggested that there could be a smartphone-free dorm, and students who live there would have to have dumb phones or no cell phones. Parties hosted there would have the same rules for all attendees. It would be like how there used to be non-smoking dorms for students and visitors who preferred to live in a smoke-free environment.

By @sideshowb - 3 months
Does anyone know more details: do that phones genuinely have no internet at all, I.e. Couldn't use WhatsApp for messaging? Interested to know how they handle that edge case.
By @moomin - 3 months
If you want to look at something that will permanently damage a kid’s psyche, maybe boarding school should be higher up your list than smartphones.
By @4gotunameagain - 3 months
I'm really glad the shift seems to have begun.

Humans are terrible in proactive action, we always wait until net negative developments really mess things up and then we are reactive. The main difference in this case is that in my opinion it is only rarely that a development plagues children so much as smartphones have.

We can only hope that the obliteration of attention spans and the cultivation of addictive behaviours will not leave lasting effects.

By @poopcat - 3 months
Honestly this seems like a good experiment. I am always looking at my phone, but I’m at a very different stage in life than the students at school. With a Nokia phone, it’s not like they wouldn’t be able to communicate with one another or with their parents.

I do worry that it might make it harder for students that struggle finding a group of peers at school and find community online.