July 12th, 2024

Students at fake university in Michigan created by ICE can sue US, court rules

Students of the fake University of Farmington, created by ICE, can sue the U.S. government for tuition refunds and damages. The court ruling signifies a moral win, stressing fairness and government accountability.

Read original articleLink Icon
Students at fake university in Michigan created by ICE can sue US, court rules

Students who enrolled at the fake University of Farmington, set up by ICE agents, have been granted the right to sue the U.S. government by a federal court ruling. The court decision allows the students, who paid tuition to the university before it was shut down by ICE in 2019, to pursue their claims for tuition refunds and punitive damages. The students argue that the government breached their contract by essentially taking their tuition money. The Department of Homeland Security, including ICE, has not commented on the ruling. The undercover operation by ICE targeted foreign-born students, leading to arrests, deportations, and students leaving the U.S. voluntarily. The court's decision is seen as a moral victory by the students, emphasizing the importance of fairness and honesty. The case highlights the government's accountability and the need for justice in such situations. The ruling could have broader implications beyond this specific case, potentially setting a legal precedent for government actions involving private parties in the future.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @olliej - 10 months
I still don't understand how anything these students did was wrong, and how anything ICE did was not fraud.

My understanding from back when this first came out was:

1. ICE created a "university" and made it as real appearing as possible

2. ICE advertised their university to non-americans

3. ICE's university told the applicants how to apply for student visas

4. The students came to what they were - by design - led to believe was a real, accredited, and good university

5. ICE arrested the students for immigration fraud and stole their tuition money

I do not understand on how (5) did not violate 4th amendment on multiple grounds, and I'm not sure how this would not be simple entrapment even if there was some belief/knowledge the school was not 100% above board.

By @acheong08 - 10 months
I would like to read from the perspective of ICE justifying this behavior. This seems like straight up fraud
By @Double_a_92 - 10 months
How can an university be fake? Like didn't those people actually go there and study?
By @blinded - 10 months
Wonder how this will jive with the supreme courts recent decisions on standing.