July 19th, 2024

Why don't they compose music like Bach any more?

The article discusses Nikolaus Matthes's Markus Passion, a contemporary composition resembling Bach's style. Matthes's work, praised for its Baroque authenticity, receives acclaim from critics and composers, questioning modern recognition.

Read original articleLink Icon
Why don't they compose music like Bach any more?

The article discusses the lack of contemporary music compositions resembling those of Bach. It highlights a recent recording by Nikolaus Matthes, Markus Passion, which mirrors Bach's style. Despite being born in 1981, Matthes's work is reminiscent of Bach's era, receiving positive reviews from critics and comparisons to Bach's cantatas. The piece has been praised for its Baroque authenticity and resemblance to Bach's music. Various reviewers commend Matthes's achievement, with one stating it could have been written by Bach himself. The work has garnered acclaim from classical music outlets and composers, emphasizing its tribute to Bach. Despite its quality, the article questions the lack of recognition and popularity for such compositions in modern times. The piece is available for purchase online, and the author contemplates revising his aesthetic views based on Matthes's work.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @al_borland - 4 months
Is this surprising? Tastes change over time. My grandfather, born in 1906 was a big fan of Enrico Caruso. I'm sure Caruso was amazing when he was popular, just like Guns & Roses were popular in their heyday, and now no one cares. Time passes, tastes changes. This is life.

The most talented artists of the day tend to work in whatever genre is popular in their era, or create their own to push music forward. They aren't looking to clone music from centuries ago.

By @beardyw - 4 months
By @ofalkaed - 4 months
Counterpoint has its limits and a good amount of what Bach is remembered for is pushing those limits and moving us beyond counterpoint, composing like Bach is antithetical to who Bach was.