July 20th, 2024

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder, Richard Stallman (2008)

Richard Stallman criticizes cloud computing as a marketing ploy, warning against data privacy risks and vendor lock-in. He advocates for user control and freedom-respecting programs over reliance on external web applications.

Read original articleLink Icon
Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder, Richard Stallman (2008)

Richard Stallman, the founder of GNU, criticizes cloud computing as a marketing hype campaign, labeling it as worse than stupidity. He argues that web-based programs like Google's Gmail are designed to lock users into costly proprietary systems over time. Stallman emphasizes the importance of keeping control of personal information rather than handing it over to third parties. He warns against the trend of storing data on internet-accessible servers, highlighting potential privacy and ownership issues. Stallman advocates for users to maintain control by doing their computing on their own machines with freedom-respecting programs. His stance aligns with concerns raised by others in the industry, such as Larry Ellison of Oracle, who dismiss cloud computing as fashion-driven gibberish. Despite the popularity of cloud computing among tech giants like Google, Microsoft, and Amazon, Stallman urges users to prioritize privacy and autonomy by avoiding reliance on external web applications.

Link Icon 2 comments
By @politelemon - 9 months
I think one of the bigger (but not necessarily earliest) indicators of the 'trap' potential in public conscience was when Adobe started moving to its "creative cloud" solution. There were constant debates about its usefulness vs the trap. Sadly it seems that the former won out with people overwhelmingly in favour of the new 'ecosystem'. It's only now (about 10 years later) that the signs are emerging which include the recent 'AI' training, the pricing, as well as difficulties involved in cancelling.

As a whole we're generally slow in realizing the problem, with the early naysayers being treated as a nuisance. Other platforms show similar signs of being a trap as well, basically any platform where we're "locked in" for our own good... but I don't know if we'll learn from past lessons.