July 25th, 2024

How the American war on porn could change the way you use the internet

Nineteen U.S. states have enacted age verification laws for online pornography to protect children, raising concerns about free speech, surveillance, and potential risks of pushing users to unregulated sites.

Read original articleLink Icon
How the American war on porn could change the way you use the internet

In the United States, a growing number of states are implementing age verification laws for accessing online pornography, significantly impacting how users engage with the internet. As of 2023, 19 states have enacted such laws, with more expected to follow, leading to widespread access restrictions on sites like Pornhub. The primary goal of these regulations is to protect children from potentially harmful content, amid concerns that pornography may normalize aggressive sexual behavior and create unrealistic expectations. Proponents argue that age verification is akin to ID checks for purchasing cigarettes, while opponents warn that these measures could push users towards less regulated and potentially more dangerous corners of the internet.

Critics of the laws, including civil rights advocates, express concerns about the implications for free speech and the potential for increased surveillance. They argue that the laws may not effectively safeguard children and could inadvertently expose them to riskier online environments. The debate is further complicated by the political landscape, with some conservative leaders advocating for a total ban on pornography, framing the issue as part of a broader moral agenda.

While some in the adult industry support age verification, they caution that current laws may not be effective and could drive users to less safe sites. The ongoing discussions around these regulations highlight a pivotal moment for internet governance, with potential ramifications for access to information and personal privacy.

Link Icon 9 comments
By @michaelt - 4 months
As I understand things, a big part of the support for age verification comes from religious groups who'd like a complete porn ban.

But as that won't fly for first amendment reasons, imposing an impractical age verification requirement is the next best thing. The impracticality is intentional, the people advocating for these laws don't want it to be possible to comply with.

By @whycome - 4 months
> According to Kekesi, every single piece of content uploaded to Pornhub is now manually reviewed by a human being.

That's ...a job.

> Device-based age verification

This seems like something Apple will inevitably get into. It could be enough pressure to deter device-sharing.

edit: and I don't mean they'll be forced to do it. They'll just use it as an opportunity. Eg, pornhub will work in Texas for 'age-verified devices" -- no ID upload required. (At least not to the site in question). Texans won't need to futz with a VPN, they'll just use iPhone. Parents will want to get their kids devices that have the verification.

By @BLKNSLVR - 4 months
What does the research say regarding the negative effects of social media on children?

Social media seems far more pervasive amongst young people than porn.

Social media ain't never going to be banned though.

By @benreesman - 4 months
Lot of fucking luck Texas et al, there’s no way this sticks. I have no idea what the new status quo will be, VPNs becoming as common as web browsers would be one amusing future, but it won’t be that these laws get complied with, that is zero percent going to happen ever.
By @sneed_chucker - 4 months
VPNs make short work of these blocks in Texas just as they do in large parts of the Middle East and Eastern Asia where porn is illegal. Assuming you're an adult and are able to pay for and set up a VPN.

That aside, I'm not convinced unfettered access to all varieties of hardcore pornography is a good thing for society, especially kids.

By @spacecadet - 4 months
Meanwhile you can go on Amazon, without signing in, and search various terms that return all variety of products depicting "porn".
By @puppycodes - 4 months
Laws written by grandparents is whats going on here.

Sure... legislate away the hormones of a teenager lol good luck.