July 26th, 2024

Evidence for global cultural diffusion: Or, why are there Seven Sisters?

The article examines cultural diffusion, highlighting similarities in myths like the Pleiades across diverse societies. It suggests a shared cultural origin or diffusion of ideas, indicating interconnected human history.

Read original articleLink Icon
Evidence for global cultural diffusion: Or, why are there Seven Sisters?

The article discusses the concept of cultural diffusion, particularly focusing on the similarities in myths and cultural elements across diverse societies, such as the Australian Aboriginals and the Navajo. It highlights the Pleiades star cluster, known as the Seven Sisters, which appears in mythologies worldwide, including those of Australia and Greece. The article raises questions about why these cultures share similar stories about the Pleiades, despite geographical separation, and why they refer to seven stars when typically only six are visible. This phenomenon suggests a possible shared cultural origin or diffusion of ideas.

The author also explores other global myths, such as serpent mythology and the concept of a primordial matriarchy, which appear in various cultures. The article references the work of anthropologists and comparative mythologists who argue that these similarities may trace back to a common cultural root in Africa around 100,000 years ago. The discussion includes themes of gender dynamics in ancient societies, as well as the role of animals, particularly dogs, in mythologies across continents.

Overall, the article posits that the striking parallels in myths and cultural practices across different societies may indicate a deeper, interconnected human history that transcends individual cultures, suggesting that certain ideas and narratives may have originated from a shared ancestral experience.

Link Icon 6 comments
By @thrance - 4 months
I see nothing that can't be explained by convergent cultural evolution. Also, what's that thing about "Shamans being able to access molecular information" ? Is the author seriously including this in his piece ? It makes it hard to take the rest seriously.
By @nullindividual - 4 months
Seven Sisters myth being a coincidence across cultures around the world:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qyjKND3dAE

By @neilv - 4 months
> The best overview of this practice I could find was chatGPT [link], so all of the (now) usual caveats. It lists practices in dozens of societies spread across every continent[8].

I don't understand why an article that starts with scholarly pretense would throw that in there.

(If the best overview you could find was ChatGPT output, and you're suggesting the usual caveats apply, why not go validate what it said, from reputable sources, rather than passing through suspected bad information?)

By @motohagiography - 4 months
is there a utilitarian school of archeology that looks at what would absolutely necessitate these things for survival? astronomy is for navigation, particularly over large distances (deserts) and at sea. music and flutes are for both signalling over distances and abstraction of language into transmissable signals for coordination. circumcision is as honest signal as possible for membership (hah!) in a group that provides security and benefits to its mothers and children. the feminine cults show that matriarchy is the harbinger of conquest, as objectively, the thing those civilizations and tribes had in common is being overrun and wiped out.

simple material explanations that can be modelled as incentives, each demonstrably essential for survival, which is the only ultimate measure of success. we don't need psychic aliens or DMT elves to make testable hypothesis' and predictions based on these necessities. Look for the physical necessities of survival instead of symbols and narratives and it probably yields better results.

By @singularity2001 - 4 months
The article is bunk but in general I still think after the invention of whaling and ocean going boats 8000-6000 BC global cultural diffusion is often the much more plausible explanation why inventions show up close in time around the chalcolithic.
By @ThinkBeat - 4 months
Or maybe humans are not particularly creative. We are not wired that differently. Two arms, two eyes, two legs, 5*2 fingers and toes. We see patterns and we try to define something around it.

Siblings are universal.