July 26th, 2024

How Clang compiles a function (2018)

The article explains how Clang compiles a simple C++ function into LLVM IR, detailing memory allocation, control flow, and the representation of loops, with a focus on unoptimized output.

Read original articleLink Icon
How Clang compiles a function (2018)

The article discusses how Clang compiles a simple C++ function, `is_sorted`, into LLVM Intermediate Representation (IR). It emphasizes a high-level overview rather than delving into Clang's internal workings or complex C++ features. The function checks if an array is sorted and is compiled using the command `clang++ is_sorted.cpp -O0 -S -emit-llvm`, which instructs Clang to produce unoptimized LLVM IR. The output includes comments and metadata about the module, such as the target architecture and data layout.

The function's structure in LLVM IR is explained, highlighting the allocation of stack memory for parameters and local variables. The translation of the for loop into basic blocks is outlined, demonstrating how Clang handles control flow. Each basic block contains instructions that must adhere to specific entry and exit rules, with the first block initializing variables and branching to the loop condition.

The article details how the loop condition and body are represented in IR, including memory operations and comparisons. It also explains the handling of the return value and the final return instruction. The author notes that Clang generates what they term "degenerate SSA code," which meets SSA requirements but relies on memory rather than direct value manipulation. The post concludes with a promise to explore LLVM IR-level optimizations in future writings.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @sidkshatriya - 4 months
Biggest insight from the article: clang does not need to generate SSA with phi nodes (which can get complicated and subtle). It can simply generate a sort of "degenerate" SSA which avoids phi nodes by storing and loading results to memory. This way the front end can concentrate on converting the front end C/C++ code to something simple.

Many of memory/load stores will be removed later in the pipeline and changed to registers. That is something for the optimization pipeline. Thats when phi nodes etc. will be insert and come into play.

By @de_aztec - 4 months
Very interesting to see that Clang basically always produces very bad and unoptimized LLVM IR code and leaves it to LLVM to clean it all up. That said, it's not entirely true that Clang avoid doing any optimizations -- it does indeed produce slightly different LLVM IR for -O0 and -O3.
By @dang - 4 months
Discussed at the time:

How Clang Compiles a Function - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17405594 - June 2018 (16 comments)