July 28th, 2024

Elon Musk Shares Manipulated Harris Video, in Seeming Violation of X's Policies

Elon Musk shared a manipulated video of Vice President Kamala Harris, raising concerns about misleading content and compliance with X's policies against deceptive media, amid growing worries about deepfake technology's impact on democracy.

Read original articleLink Icon
Elon Musk Shares Manipulated Harris Video, in Seeming Violation of X's Policies

Elon Musk, the owner of the social media platform X, recently shared a manipulated video of Vice President Kamala Harris that alters her voice to make misleading statements about President Biden and her qualifications. The video, which was originally released by the Harris campaign, was edited to remove references to Donald Trump and to include misleading content, such as claims that Biden is senile. Musk reposted the video without a disclaimer, stating only, "This is amazing," which has raised concerns about compliance with X's policies against sharing deceptive media. Critics, including digital governance experts, have pointed out that Musk's actions appear to violate these policies, which prohibit synthetic or manipulated media that could mislead the public. The Harris campaign responded by emphasizing the importance of truthful representation in political discourse. The rise of deepfake technology has prompted alarm among pro-democracy groups, as such content can significantly impact voter behavior and the democratic process. The Federal Election Commission is considering amendments to clarify regulations regarding AI-generated political content, but the current law remains ambiguous. Other social media platforms, like Meta and Google, have stricter policies requiring clear labeling of manipulated media. Despite the backlash, Musk has not addressed the criticism or removed the post, which has garnered millions of views. His influence on X, with 191 million followers, allows him to amplify content rapidly, raising further concerns about the spread of misinformation in the lead-up to elections.

Link Icon 13 comments
By @beeman - 3 months
By @davda - 3 months
This is not unexpected, but I think he's reaching bit too far to use it on presidential nominee. It could very well kick off strict AI regulation whether Harris is elected or not, which would be amusing to see given he's trying to get the Tesla shareholders to invest in his very own xAI. AOC's deepfake AI porn tri-partisan bill had no trouble passing the senate.
By @two_handfuls - 3 months
To the surprise of absolutely no one who had been paying attention.
By @tim333 - 3 months
The post / video: https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1816974609637417112

While it doesn't say 'satire' or not real it's kind of obviously satire to me at any rate within the first few seconds. Guess this stuff can be a grey area especially if it's more subtle.

By the way the original video post had "Kamala Harris Campaign Ad PARODY" written on it but Musk removed that when he reposted. (https://x.com/MrReaganUSA/status/1816826660089733492)

By @cowboylowrez - 3 months
Elon is ridiculous, and so is twitter. Its banned where I work tho, because the ownership desires normal internet.
By @skeledrew - 3 months
There is a "relatively simple"[0] solution to this issue of deepfakes. Anyone publishing content, particularly if there is incentive for manipulation, can get a Keyoxide[1] or other similar doip setup. Then they also sign and provider a hash of any content they publish with the associated key.

There's a bit of challenge for binary content since those can't be compressed or optimized without breaking the hash, and many hosting platforms will make such changes. For that we need to advance perceptual hashing algos to the point where they only - and always - break on semantic differences.

[0] Caveat being getting the solution to be seamless enough for the not-so-tech-inclined to have little problem using it. And for the general public to get into the habit of verifying content.

[1] https://keyoxide.org/

By @jerojero - 3 months
It is his platform after all, he can post whatever he wants.

On the other hand, this is one of the reasons why the platform is really becoming unusable for me. Not to mention everyday i'm "followed" by 5-10 bots. And I get recommended a lot of posts about right wing posters that I have no interest in seeing. I mean, ofc, I don't have to use the fyp but I do wonder if there's manipulation of the algorithm going on. I don't follow any accounts that are right-wing aligned.

By @hn1986 - 3 months
The billionaire owner of the social media platform X reposted a video that mimics Vice President Kamala Harris’s voice, without disclosing that it had been altered
By @SuperNinKenDo - 3 months
What an absolute reach. Somebody is going to watch this and think it's a real Harris campaign ad? Get a grip on reality, nobody with a working brain will.
By @infotainment - 3 months
Don’t worry, I’m sure in a day or two the policies will be rewritten with an awkwardly shoehorned-in exception.