August 1st, 2024

Will Britain Survive? (2022)

Britain faces existential challenges in 2022, struggling with national identity amid crises from Brexit, COVID-19, and economic decline, raising concerns about its unity and future as a cohesive nation.

Read original articleLink Icon
Will Britain Survive? (2022)

Britain faces significant existential challenges as it enters 2022, marked by a series of crises that threaten its unity and identity. The country has experienced setbacks, including the fallout from the 2008 financial crisis, the divisive impact of Brexit, and a poorly managed response to the COVID-19 pandemic, resulting in high death rates and economic decline. These events have exposed deep-seated issues within the United Kingdom, which comprises England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, leading to a crisis of national identity. Many citizens struggle to define what it means to be British, with divisions exacerbated by Brexit, which highlighted the unequal nature of the union, particularly the dominance of England in decision-making.

The article draws parallels between Britain's current situation and historical empires that faced dissolution due to internal strife and failure to adapt. Observations from a recent road trip across the UK reveal a nation grappling with its past and future, where traditional institutions coexist with modern multiculturalism. The author reflects on the significance of places like Butlin's, a holiday resort that embodies a unique British identity, contrasting it with more exclusive, gentrified areas. This journey underscores the complexities of national belonging in a country that is increasingly questioning its coherence and purpose. The overarching sentiment is one of uncertainty about whether Britain can maintain its unity amid rising nationalism and identity crises, raising the question of its future as a cohesive nation.

Related

UK's Housing Crisis Needs a London-Sized City to Fix It

UK's Housing Crisis Needs a London-Sized City to Fix It

The UK faces a severe housing crisis, needing to build a city the size of London to catch up with decades of under-construction. Both parties promise solutions, but challenges hinder progress.

Why Britain is the worst on homelessness

Why Britain is the worst on homelessness

The UK faces severe homelessness issues, with 1 in 200 households in emergency lodging. Rising due to housing unaffordability, poor conditions impact adults and children. Urgent action is needed to boost housing supply and affordability.

The UK's Brexit dream is dead

The UK's Brexit dream is dead

The UK's Brexit journey faces challenges as key figures exit, radical plans are abandoned, and promised benefits fail to materialize. New trade agreements mirror EU deals, impacting GDP and US trade prospects. Immigration policies struggle post-Brexit, causing tensions and unmet promises.

The UK can go back to being the richest country in the world

The UK can go back to being the richest country in the world

The UK aims to regain global wealth, focusing on economic gaps between regions like the Greater South East and North England. Emphasis on historical strengths in areas like Bradford and the necessity for enhanced infrastructure and government aid to boost Northern economy. Calls for reduced fiscal transfers, increased investments, and balanced government support to drive economic success and address regional inequalities for overall prosperity.

Britain is running out of babies

Britain is running out of babies

Britain's birth rates are declining, projected to decrease primary school-aged children by 10% in four years. This trend raises concerns about economic and social challenges due to an aging population.

Link Icon 5 comments
By @physicsguy - 3 months
2 years on from this, the SNP are in pretty dire straits after scandals engulfing the husband of former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland has just elected 30 Labour MPs and the country as a whole has ejected the Tory government.
By @josefritzishere - 3 months
By @alephnerd - 3 months
Of course it's an UnHerd editor who wrote this.

Britain will survive. It will look different from the Britain of the 1990s, like how the Britain of rhe 1990s looked entirely different from the Britain of the 1960s.

> From England, we ventured north into Scotland, which today feels almost like a foreign country

Yet the SNP is dying an electoral death as Labour and even the Conservatives gain vote share.

> Nominally, Britain has a National Health Service, but in practice this has been broken up into its component (sub)national parts

And why should the NHS be centralized?

Health indicators and issues in Cornwall are going to be distinct from those in London or Yorkshire.

Medical care is inherently community driven, and this requires health providers being attuned to local conditions in a way that central control cannot provide.

This is why Canada also created localized single payer groups.

> attempts to rebuild a sense of Britishness will remain marginal

Then accept that you can be British and <insert-ethnic-identity-here>. The UK absolutely needs to federalize, as broad stroke identities like "English" or "Scottish" mask the diversity that exists in the UK.

Instead of centralizing everything in London, empower Regional Assemblies or even convert them into states.

The amount of central control London has is archaic compared to peer states by population (Germany, France, Turkey, etc).

> And while there is no active British state to speak of in Scotland

Smh, this is basically assuming being British means being Londonian with extra steps.