What NYC Lost When It Lost Congestion Pricing
Governor Hochul's pause on congestion pricing jeopardizes $15 billion in funding for New York City's MTA, risking service cuts, fare hikes, and thousands of jobs amid rising operational costs.
Read original article
Governor Kathy Hochul's decision to indefinitely pause congestion pricing has significant implications for New York City's Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA). The tolling plan was expected to generate $15 billion for the transit system, but its suspension has left a substantial financial gap. MTA Chair Janno Lieber expressed concern over the lack of a viable alternative to replace this funding, which is critical for maintaining and expanding transit services. The MTA faces escalating costs, including $50 million in 2025 for maintaining older buses and $20 million annually for replacing commuter trains. Additionally, the agency will incur $90 million per year by 2026 due to increased overtime and contractor costs for maintaining aging infrastructure.
The loss of congestion pricing also threatens approximately 7,000 union jobs tied to construction projects, potentially costing $100 million in 2025 and $200 million in 2026. Lieber outlined three potential outcomes: failure to reach a deal, borrowing against operational funds leading to service cuts and fare hikes, or finding alternative funding sources. Hochul's initial proposal to replace the lost revenue was rejected, and other suggestions, such as taxing businesses or expanding gambling, have not gained traction. The ongoing traffic congestion in Manhattan, exacerbated by the pandemic, highlights the urgent need for effective transit solutions. Without congestion pricing, the MTA risks a financial crisis that could severely impact public transportation and the city's recovery.
Related
Why it takes NYC nearly 10 years to install 500 feet of pipes – Gothamist
Construction delays along York Avenue in NYC, lasting over 8 years due to unexpected gas and steam line discoveries, have inflated costs. Officials advocate for contracting reforms to enhance efficiency and reduce expenses.
The Death of NYC Congestion Pricing
New York City cancels congestion pricing scheme due to inflation concerns, impacting transit projects like Second Avenue Subway Phase II. Critics question MTA's financial management. Decision reflects challenges in infrastructure planning.
New York Should Tax Parking Spaces, Not Streets, to End Standoff
New York City considers alternative revenue sources like congestion pricing and a payroll tax due to a budget shortfall. Columnist Andrew Leahey proposes taxing parking spaces as a politically feasible option to raise funds and reduce congestion, emphasizing the need for public support and gradual implementation.
Cities Can Use Paris as a Model for Implementing Safer Street Infrastructure
Cities like New York can learn from Paris's successful urban transportation policies, including congestion pricing and pedestrian-friendly initiatives, to improve residents' quality of life and transportation efficiency. Paris's approach involves transforming streets, limiting car speeds, creating car-free zones, and investing in non-car transportation modes. US cities can benefit from prioritizing pedestrians, alternative transportation modes, and congestion pricing for public transportation improvements, leading to reduced traffic and enhanced safety.
The MTA's Oldest Controls Kept Going During the Tech Outage
Amid a global tech outage, New York City's MTA relied on old but reliable systems to transport 5 million passengers. Efforts to upgrade technology continue for enhanced efficiency and reliability.
2 commentsRelated
Why it takes NYC nearly 10 years to install 500 feet of pipes – Gothamist
Construction delays along York Avenue in NYC, lasting over 8 years due to unexpected gas and steam line discoveries, have inflated costs. Officials advocate for contracting reforms to enhance efficiency and reduce expenses.
The Death of NYC Congestion Pricing
New York City cancels congestion pricing scheme due to inflation concerns, impacting transit projects like Second Avenue Subway Phase II. Critics question MTA's financial management. Decision reflects challenges in infrastructure planning.
New York Should Tax Parking Spaces, Not Streets, to End Standoff
New York City considers alternative revenue sources like congestion pricing and a payroll tax due to a budget shortfall. Columnist Andrew Leahey proposes taxing parking spaces as a politically feasible option to raise funds and reduce congestion, emphasizing the need for public support and gradual implementation.
Cities Can Use Paris as a Model for Implementing Safer Street Infrastructure
Cities like New York can learn from Paris's successful urban transportation policies, including congestion pricing and pedestrian-friendly initiatives, to improve residents' quality of life and transportation efficiency. Paris's approach involves transforming streets, limiting car speeds, creating car-free zones, and investing in non-car transportation modes. US cities can benefit from prioritizing pedestrians, alternative transportation modes, and congestion pricing for public transportation improvements, leading to reduced traffic and enhanced safety.
The MTA's Oldest Controls Kept Going During the Tech Outage
Amid a global tech outage, New York City's MTA relied on old but reliable systems to transport 5 million passengers. Efforts to upgrade technology continue for enhanced efficiency and reliability.